Story feedback Request

Planetdoom

New member
Joined
Jan 15, 2026
Messages
1
Points
3
I am a new writer and i want honest feedback on my WIP story. So far I have 42 chapters and i have much more in store, but i want to make sure I'm doing everything right so I'm reaching out.

https://www.scribblehub.com/series/2116848/a-second-chance-to-ruin/

This is my first time doing something like this so I'm a little nervous, but i do genuinely want feedback. Whoever wants to read my story, you don't have to read all of it but if you want go ahead. please give me feedback if you have the time and if you are interested.

the feedback can be anything, it can be specific points or the entire story. Anything helps, feedback on the pacing, the characters, the plot, or the world building is enough.
 

Eldoria

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 14, 2025
Messages
1,578
Points
113
I've read up to 6 chapters... my overall impression is that your fiction is quite good at depicting what's happening, "oh... this is an isekai story with mystery elements?!"

But, you haven't reached the level of impressing me as a casual reader to say, "Wow... I was shocked when the MC suddenly entered an isekai." Why?

This is a classic problem... your fiction is dominated by telling rather than showing.

Telling is not wrong but emotionally distant. Telling makes you place the reader as a neutral observer.

The reader is only told... instead of experiencing the world through the protagonist.

The principle of "Show it, don't tell it" is simple but complicated to apply.

However, once you master it... your fiction will feel immersive.

No longer just talking, "what happened to the character" but "what does the reader feel through the character?"

The solution?

First, you can use a limited third POV - only narrating what the protagonist experiences sensorially.

Second, reduce direct emotions (such as words of sad, happy, etc).

Third, increase sensory narratives such as visuals (e.g. sky blue eyes), sounds (e.g. onomatopoeia of the river sound "ssrrrttt..."), tastes (e.g. salty sweat), touch (e.g. gravelly ground), physiological (e.g. nauseous stomach) and mental states (e.g. inner voice and anxiety).

That way, your narrative will be more powerful and immersive.

Hopefully this brief feedback helps you (or maybe not).

Regards.


Critical Note:
As a causal reader, I only read once per chapter and do not repeat.

You managed to make me read up to 6 chapters without a break before I stopped for external reasons.

Your pacing is good. It just lacks reader's experience.

This does not mean that telling is not allowed... telling is needed to speed up pacing such as time skips, avoiding descriptive repetition, and highlighting emotions after showing. Please read the following this thread.

You might be worried that if you use too much showing then the pacing will slow down. The solution?

You can use cinematic action narrative. Start with action followed by description/effect.

For example, you can introduce the protagonist by waking up while showing physical descriptions such as messy black hair, sunken eyes, etc. This way, pacing will be smooth.

Lastly, your fiction's engagement is low... this may be a problem with the packaging (cover, title, synopsis, tags, and chapter numbering), release schedule, and promotion.

Feedback on engagement could be a separate thread, or you could explore engagement tips for new fiction.

I've covered this many times... and tried to give you some tips. But I had a hard time finding my answers among the thousands of threads.

If you're willing to bother, please explore those threads, especially the general authors section.
 
Last edited:

SouthernMaiden

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 11, 2025
Messages
168
Points
63
You're writing is actually fairly evocative. But your chapters seem very short. How many words are youe chapters on average?
 

Eldoria

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 14, 2025
Messages
1,578
Points
113
You're writing is actually fairly evocative. But your chapters seem very short. How many words are youe chapters on average?
It's a smart engagement strategy. Short chapters are useful for addressing the limited attention span of casual readers, especially at the beginning of a series.

However, the fiction chapters are getting longer. Statistics show the average word count per chapter is around 1,2k words, and this will likely continue to increase as the number of chapters increases.

Unfortunately, this short chapter strategy is not as effective in his fiction, as his engagement is low.
 

Louhi

Squire of the Enpire
Joined
Jul 20, 2020
Messages
77
Points
93
It's a smart engagement strategy. Short chapters are useful for addressing the limited attention span of casual readers, especially at the beginning of a series.

However, the fiction chapters are getting longer. Statistics show the average word count per chapter is around 1,2k words, and this will likely continue to increase as the number of chapters increases.

Unfortunately, this short chapter strategy is not as effective in his fiction, as his engagement is low.
I think the problem is the site's anti-spam mechanism getting triggered from releasing 39 chapters at the same day.
 
Top