New cover art

[GodlessEmperor]

I made my last cover at 3 am and while I fixed it somewhat it still is bad. So, I finally sat down and started drawing a new one, but I didn't like how it was turning out. I say "new" but the plan was just to "improve" the art. I'm not creative enough to think of something new. I also didn't like that the old one is 25x350 at full scale, I have to scale it because of that. I wanted to have more details in the art but I have no idea what I'm doing so...yeah. I also wanted to add some clickbait booba.
Should I continue making the new one or just leave the cover as it is?
Old (for mobile users that don't see my signature) vs. New (WIP):

Maybe I should just draw a generic woman hip-up and add the title or something.

 

[Deleted member 58005]

I actually like the cartoonish and basic style of the first one more.

The second looks way too... unfinished, at least for the girl.

 

[MissPaige36]

I made my last cover at 3 am and while I fixed it somewhat it still is bad. So, I finally sat down and started drawing a new one, but I didn't like how it was turning out. I say "new" but the plan was just to "improve" the art. I'm not creative enough to think of something new. I also didn't like that the old one is 25x350 at full scale, I have to scale it because of that. I wanted to have more details in the art but I have no idea what I'm doing so...yeah. I also wanted to add some clickbait booba.
Should I continue making the new one or just leave the cover as it is?
Old (for mobile users that don't see my signature) vs. New:

Maybe I should just draw a generic woman hip-up and add the title or something.

The old one works fine if you ask me

 

[Minx]

I made my last cover at 3 am and while I fixed it somewhat it still is bad. So, I finally sat down and started drawing a new one, but I didn't like how it was turning out. I say "new" but the plan was just to "improve" the art. I'm not creative enough to think of something new. I also didn't like that the old one is 25x350 at full scale, I have to scale it because of that. I wanted to have more details in the art but I have no idea what I'm doing so...yeah. I also wanted to add some clickbait booba.
Should I continue making the new one or just leave the cover as it is?if you
Old (for mobile users that don't see my signature) vs. New:

Maybe I should just draw a generic woman hip-up and add the title or something.

If you add a bit of color to the new one, I'd say go for it but.

 

[Anon_Y_Mousse]

The older one is way more vibrant despite the cartoony style tbh(but I'm no artist so take my words with a grain of salt.) I recommend taking the design of the door and keeping the portal tbh.

 

[GodlessEmperor]

If you add a bit of color to the new one, I'd say go for it but.

The older one is way more vibrant despite the cartoony style tbh(but I'm no artist so take my words with a grain of salt.) I recommend taking the design of the door and keeping the portal tbh.

Since I stopped midway the new one is still missing most of it. But yeah, I'll probably stay with the older one. Just changing the door style will be hard, since I'm crazy and did everything in only 3 layers for no reason.
I'll try myself on it again once I manage to motivate myself in a month or so.