Recommendations Mystery + Drama + ... Isekai?

zac_k4ry

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 5, 2020
Messages
34
Points
48
Okay so I feel the reader community of ScribbleHub really has an audience for the isekai novels. But, I can't really seem to find that. It's been like two weeks, and not even a single response, as it seems. My series is currently ongoing, and it's got elements of action, drama, and mystery. It's not just a typical isekai novel with comedy or great fight scenes. Rather, it's an isekai I myself want to read... an isekai where the 'isekai' is not just limited to one guy being teleported and forgotten in the real realm. Please, give it a try. At least, read the first episodes. I hope you'd like it.
 

Cipiteca396

Monarch of Despair 🐉🌺🪽🌊🪶🌑🐦‍🔥🌈
Joined
Jun 6, 2021
Messages
2,700
Points
153
The title is extremely generic(and that's coming from me of all people), the synopsis is a little off-putting due to lack of clarity and 'wall of text' syndrome, and you uploaded all of your chapters too closely together.

If you upload too many chapters at once, there's less time for your story to be on the front page where people can see it.

Step one, upload at a time when people are online to see it.

Step two, space out your uploads, 4 hours between each upload at a minimum. It would be better to have 12 or 24 hours between uploads instead, though.

Step three, properly utilize tags. You can have up to eight genres and twenty five tags. Tags make it more likely for people who weren't looking at the front page when you uploaded to notice your story. Obviously, it's important to only include tags that are relevant to your work, but it's not difficult to include common tags like 'Male Protagonist'.

Your cover is nice, though, so don't worry about that. Glancing through your first few chapters, you absolutely need to work on breaking up some of your paragraphs. The Wall of Text is a horrific enemy that not every reader will be willing to confront.

Your use of language and grammar needs serious work, and SH users rarely bother to complain about that kind of thing. They either ignore it or drop the story entirely. There are several threads where you can ask for advice, but I don't know how seriously they take editing. They might just do what I did and say, 'Needs work, who's next?'.
 

Jemini

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 27, 2019
Messages
2,037
Points
153
Okay so I feel the reader community of ScribbleHub really has an audience for the isekai novels. But, I can't really seem to find that. It's been like two weeks, and not even a single response, as it seems. My series is currently ongoing, and it's got elements of action, drama, and mystery. It's not just a typical isekai novel with comedy or great fight scenes. Rather, it's an isekai I myself want to read... an isekai where the 'isekai' is not just limited to one guy being teleported and forgotten in the real realm. Please, give it a try. At least, read the first episodes. I hope you'd like it.

Replace "mystery" with atmospheric world building, and you have pretty much just described my series as well.

Anyway, think you need to listen to some of this feedback. The marketing you are doing for your series is really not as good as it could be.

I've done a little looking into what attracts eyeballs and have put quite a bit of thought into my image for my series. I also admit I'm not really optimizing it. I'm intentionally not playing the system. I would rather not be cheap or have shallow followers. But, anyway, I would say it's working still considering my reader count.

Anyway, yes. Female characters on the cover often pushes it hard, especially a single female character in a vulnerable pose. That's cheap, but it's what attracts the most eyeballs. (You will notice, I have 2 female characters, and they are in a combative stance that screams strength and adventure. Not weakness. So, as I said, intentionally missing that "cheap eyeballs" zone, but still grazing the territory.)

For the title, there are 3 key words that attract a lot of eyeballs. "Isekai," "Reincarnated," or "liteRPG." Words or phrases that have similar meanings work just as well as those three as well. However, you cannot just say one of those words by itself and expect it to work out. The market is flooded, so you need to give more details and only just include one of the 3 key words as something of an "oh, and also it's this" sort of thing.

The rest of your title should give some inkling as to what kind of story the reader should be expecting. Why does the reader want to read your story? They need to be pulled in by your title. And, as I said. Just saying "Isekai" by itself is not enough. There are plenty of Isekai out there. So, just saying that is not enough. Not by a long shot.

(Also, the fact that your story's description sounds like it really could also be describing my story as well definitely means you have a problem. Your story really doesn't stand out as much as you might think it does, even with that description. So, you should put a little more thought into what actually makes your story unique. You will notice. I just said twice how your description could also be describing my own story. However, none of the things you brought up are in my synopsis. That's because the info in my synopsis and the things I actually push about my own story are the factors that actually make mine more unique and stand out from the rest. So, that's another thing to be thinking about. Try to develop more of an identity for your story.)
 
Last edited:

Maldon

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 11, 2021
Messages
90
Points
73
The title is incredibly generic, to the point it almost feels like filler on the page, And your blurb isn't very good for annyone who did decide to click on your page, it's just one big block of text.
The massive walls of text seem to be a big issue for your story in general, they're a chore to read.
You also released a bunch of chapters all in the same day, personally I think that you should've spaced those out more, not only does it put your story on the main page more times, but it also leaves you more time to actually write the chapters while still giving readers something.
 

Arkus86

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 1, 2019
Messages
781
Points
133
You advertise your story as Isekai, but the synopsis sounds as if they never leave their world. And another world is an integral part of the Isekai genre.
 

CarburetorThompson

Fuel Atomization Enjoyer
Joined
Jan 27, 2022
Messages
1,630
Points
153
It's a meme how long the names of Japanese isekai light novels and mangas are but there is a good reason for it. It may not sound very cool, but if you can throw your synopsis at the reader in the title, they can get an idea what it is about without even clicking on it. You can see this in a bunch of the top sorted isekai stories on the site.

I haven't posted what I've worked on yet, but I imagine how a new author would get the majority of new readers is through the new series, and recently updated postings. Especially with the large amount of isekai writing on that part of the site, a distinct title is definitely needed to set you apart. I'm talking like the "I became a deep-sea crab fisherman in another world, and now I can't pay the isekai IRS" kind of title.
 

Lloyd

Funny Guy :)
Joined
Jun 2, 2020
Messages
2,538
Points
153
You gotta time your releases better.
Also I can tell just from reading a short bit it is way too wordy. Personally I'm a big believer in trimming the fat before posting to a website like SH.
 

Renaxan

Enthusiastic about a lot of things.
Joined
Jan 2, 2019
Messages
131
Points
83
Wall of text at the first paragraph... that would make the majority of casual readers run away from your story so perhaps... first... try to edit that.

The first impression is always important you know?
 
Top