Make up names or use English or Japanese or etc. names?

SilvCrimBlac

A Historical Bastard
Joined
Apr 7, 2019
Messages
332
Points
103
So, when writing, who here prefers to make up their own fantasy-ish names or use English or Japanese or (insert whatever names here) some other kinds of names for characters?

For those who chose to use already known names rather than make their own up, do you use your own language or a foreign one?

Also, for those who use a foreign one, do you always feel like you need to set the story in the same country as the name, or at least in a made-up country that shares similarities to the language the names are under, such as similar food or culture or etc.?

An example would be, an English speaker using a Japanese sounding name, would you then make your story set in Japan, or set in a made-country similar to Japan? Or, would you have it set in an area that share no similarities at all? Like for example, using a Japanese-sounding named character, with the world this character dwells in being prehistorical, or medieval-west, or just zany and alien-ish.
 

Minx

Procrastinator Mongrel
Joined
Apr 22, 2019
Messages
492
Points
133
If the MC is Japanese, I'd named Another World with a western name. There are many reasons why—one of them being able to tell the difference between heroes and normal people. It would be good too if black hair is considered rare there. Of course MC can also hide his special characteristic, but he will still stand out due to his modern common sense being way off the roof in comparison to the common sense of that fantasy world.

Long story short, I like to make up names with a little bit of lore and usage for the plot, of course I use a random name generator when I can't come up with anything good.
 

Ai-chan

Queen of Yuri Devourer of Traps
Joined
Dec 23, 2018
Messages
1,675
Points
153
So, when writing, who here prefers to make up their own fantasy-ish names or use English or Japanese or (insert whatever names here) some other kinds of names for characters?

For those who chose to use already known names rather than make their own up, do you use your own language or a foreign one?

Also, for those who use a foreign one, do you always feel like you need to set the story in the same country as the name, or at least in a made-up country that shares similarities to the language the names are under, such as similar food or culture or etc.?

An example would be, an English speaker using a Japanese sounding name, would you then make your story set in Japan, or set in a made-country similar to Japan? Or, would you have it set in an area that share no similarities at all? Like for example, using a Japanese-sounding named character, with the world this character dwells in being prehistorical, or medieval-west, or just zany and alien-ish.
If it's isekai, Ai-chan would either use Japanese, Malay or English name. Ai-chan doesn't know enough German to use German name. But for fantasy, Ai-chan usually program a random name generator for Ai-chan's own use.

Examples of characters named by random name generator are
1. Nefesukaya (Nefeskaya) from Hero Prince(ss)
2. Eruberu Sentanaria (Albell Sentnaria) from The Bride's Groom
3. Hefumefu from Masked Knight
4. Furimu (Freme) from The Tavern Mistress (title may change when published)

And now Ai-chan is programming another random name generator, the all encompassing Ultimate Name Assistant!
 
D

Deleted member 54065

Guest
So, when writing, who here prefers to make up their own fantasy-ish names or use English or Japanese or (insert whatever names here) some other kinds of names for characters?

For those who chose to use already known names rather than make their own up, do you use your own language or a foreign one?

Also, for those who use a foreign one, do you always feel like you need to set the story in the same country as the name, or at least in a made-up country that shares similarities to the language the names are under, such as similar food or culture or etc.?

An example would be, an English speaker using a Japanese sounding name, would you then make your story set in Japan, or set in a made-country similar to Japan? Or, would you have it set in an area that share no similarities at all? Like for example, using a Japanese-sounding named character, with the world this character dwells in being prehistorical, or medieval-west, or just zany and alien-ish.
It's a mix for me because I focus more on the narrative than the meaning of the name of the characters.

Plus, it feels authentic (for me) to have a character named Bob thrown in a story about friendship than one named Tomodachi Nakama in a story about bonds and friendship.
 

ThrillingHuman

always be casual, never be careless
Joined
Feb 13, 2019
Messages
4,738
Points
183
who here prefers to make up their own fantasy-ish names
I prefer to do that. Sometimes I cheekily add a foreign name or an English one, but to a character who has no ties to any Earthling state. Extremely rarely do I imply that a character is from an existing place (2, more or less characters of this variety is all I have in all my stories rn).
As a German I feel insulted
Have a pretzel and some beer with sparkling water:coffee:?
 

T.K._Paradox

Was Divided By Zero: Found Glovebox Jesus
Joined
Nov 2, 2021
Messages
1,069
Points
153
If the MC is Japanese, I'd named Another World with a western name. There are many reasons why—one of them being able to tell the difference between heroes and normal people. It would be good too if black hair is considered rare there. Of course MC can also hide his special characteristic, but he will still stand out due to his modern common sense being way off the roof in comparison to the common sense of that fantasy world.

Long story short, I like to make up names with a little bit of lore and usage for the plot, of course I use a random name generator when I can't come up with anything good.
The thing is it ain't just black hair that singles the MC out. If all these people look European, as an Asian he or she would really stand out.
 

AliceShiki

Magical Girl of Love and Justice
Joined
Dec 23, 2018
Messages
3,529
Points
183
I honestly am very whimsical with my naming sense. I choose whatever names I think will feel good.

My surnames feel more western though.
 

BearlyAlive

I'm not savage, you're just average
Joined
Oct 13, 2021
Messages
1,981
Points
153
Don't know, don't care. I literally named half of my antagonists (bad) puns. Like "Hareem Shoo-Jinko" for an isekai MC wannabe or "Armin von Dapast (a meme from the past)" for a character that (unknowingly) uses old memes
 

Ilikewaterkusa

You have to take out their families...
Joined
May 21, 2021
Messages
2,373
Points
153
So, when writing, who here prefers to make up their own fantasy-ish names or use English or Japanese or (insert whatever names here) some other kinds of names for characters?

For those who chose to use already known names rather than make their own up, do you use your own language or a foreign one?

Also, for those who use a foreign one, do you always feel like you need to set the story in the same country as the name, or at least in a made-up country that shares similarities to the language the names are under, such as similar food or culture or etc.?

An example would be, an English speaker using a Japanese sounding name, would you then make your story set in Japan, or set in a made-country similar to Japan? Or, would you have it set in an area that share no similarities at all? Like for example, using a Japanese-sounding named character, with the world this character dwells in being prehistorical, or medieval-west, or just zany and alien-ish.
Mix
 
Top