Legality?

[MouseDestruction]

Legal aged girl lose virginity while drunk, she probably would of done it sober anyway, but feels sad that she was drunk. Legal or no?

EDIT: this is story advice not real life stuff by the way lol

 

[owotrucked]

illegal in US apparently

 

[Prince_Azmiran_Myrian]

Depends on what country or state you are in.

This topic can be controversial.
@ControversialOpinion what's your take?

 

[TheEldritchGod]

She can retroactively make it illegal, by law, up to and including the expiring of the statute of limitations, in the US and England.

 

[Lloyd]

Totally legal in Italy and many other places around the world.

 

[LunaSoltaer]

You should be able to write it and be fine.

I interpret "illegal content" as things illegal to put in a book otherwise basically every book ever fails.

The other main line is "Don't encourage illegal sex acts" which you should be fine unless youre saying "Drunk Sex Is Awesome Go Do It Now!" or something.

And for the "may cause" clauses, you can't control other people, so for like 99.9% of purposes those may as well not exist

 

[Rhaps]

Legally speak, no. But in books, go wild, there may be an upper limit but nothing said about how wide you can make it.

Just remember, it is all fiction. The real problem starts when you do it irl.

 

[Rezcore]

Just don't fuck drunk. Like driving and operating heavy machinery it's generally a bad idea, and not as fun.

 

[TheEldritchGod]

Just don't fuck drunk. Like driving and operating heavy machinery it's generally a bad idea, and not as fun.

If both parties are drunk, it comes down to who files charges first. And yes, men can file charges against women if they have sex with you while you are drunk. The thing is, it comes down to who files charges first, thus locking out the other person from filing charges.

 

[Placeholder]

> Legal aged girl lose virginity while drunk, she probably would of done it sober anyway, but feels sad that she was drunk. Legal or no?

As a layperson, I know from casually reading the news that in many judiciaries, US and otherwise, cases like this are successfully prosecuted every day.

While simultaneously, actual rape kits go untested.

There is the expression "bad cases" make bad law. And your scenario is waaaay underspecified.

For your purposes, specify {Did she consent?} {How impared was she?} {Was the other participant a predator?} {Does the legal establishment and society persecute women and the other participant, etc.}

 

[Theirl]

Legal aged girl lose virginity while drunk, she probably would of done it sober anyway, but feels sad that she was drunk. Legal or no?

EDIT: this is story advice not real life stuff by the way lol

its only illegal if she go the police xD

 

[Placeholder]

Also, on a societal level, we don't want people raping drunk women.

 

[Theirl]

Also, on a societal level, we don't want people raping drunk women.

true, but it is a gray zone how do u know consent when she is drunk, and what if u are drunk too its hard the best is just to not go after the girl if she is too drunk

 

[greyblob]

what's the legality issue here?

 

[Representing_Tromba]

Legal aged girl lose virginity while drunk, she probably would of done it sober anyway, but feels sad that she was drunk. Legal or no?

EDIT: this is story advice not real life stuff by the way lol

Legal. She is of age so it's okay. if she was drunk though then it's not morally okay.

 

[owotrucked]

its only illegal if she go the police xD

it's only illegal to rob people if they go to the police, so make sure they can't

 

[Placeholder]

OP hasn't f***ing specified anything.

Scenario 1: She was unconscious at a party when a stranger penetrated her vaginally.

Scenario 2: She was unconscious at a party when a stranger penetrated her vaginally. For plot reasons, she enjoyed it.

Scenario 3: She got slightly drunk with her female crush, flirted, then blacked out - when she came to herself, they were having sex. The next day, marriage!

And we have absolutely no blasted idea what scenario OP is contemplating. Absolutely none.

It's like:"Oh hey, I'm too busy to give you details, but is it ethical to kill or eat the mammal in my living room? " "Should I take this pill from a medicine cabinet - it's a secret whether or not it's my medicine cabinet?" "I once found a piece of string. I was drunk. How long was the piece of string."

> Legal. She is of age so it's okay.

The question is underspecified - we don't even know if she was conscious, secretly horny, or ever saw the other person's/peoples' face(s)?

Or even if there's a legal system.

 

[Rezcore]

If both parties are drunk, it comes down to who files charges first. And yes, men can file charges against women if they have sex with you while you are drunk. The thing is, it comes down to who files charges first, thus locking out the other person from filing charges.

Tis true in theory. In reality weight of belief falls heavier on her side. Us dudes are basically fucked

 

[Placeholder]

The trick is to not have sex with drunk people.

 

[Theirl]

it's only illegal to rob people if they go to the police, so make sure they can't

based