[Introspection] Developing The Scene

greyblob

"Staff Memeber" pleasr
Joined
Feb 6, 2021
Messages
2,743
Points
153
This is an attempt at deconstructing the scene and creating a formula for it. The objective is not to discard or marginalise the creative process but to reinforce and guide it.


Any scene consists of a bunch of properties. I only want to focus on
  • Purpose
  • Structure and vision
  • Perspective
  • Setting
  • Details
Purpose
What is the point of this scene? What purpose does it serve? Is it necessary? If I remove it, will the story be affected?

Structure and vision
This is a bit abstract. How will this scene be structured? How will it look? Do I want it to be linear (intro-climax-end) or something a little different.

Perspective
The perspective the scene is told from.

Setting
Setting of the scene. Very important. Best resource for improvisation.

Details
For this section I wanted to make a cheatsheet by categorizing similar details into sections.
  • Sensory
    • Sight
      • Color
      • Shape
    • Touch
      • Texture
      • Temperature
      • Sensation
    • Smell
    • Sound
      • Internal
      • External
    • Taste
  • Motion
    • Action
    • Movement/Gestures
    • Conscious
    • Subconscious
  • Perception
    • Thoughts
    • Memories
    • Emotions


Constructing a scene
I have two routes here. Either I know the purpose or I have the vision.

  • I know the purpose
I want to introduce a new character. He's a struggling artist. He got a lucky (or unlucky) break. His latest painting impressed an entity unknown by most.

How do I approach this? This is a subjective process. Everyone will have their way of going about it. I usually start by thinking of a plausible action or scenario. This is an artist. He's broke. He wants to make some money. He tries selling his art. Art gallery.

Now, I have a scenario and a setting. The artist will be at an art gallery trying to showcase his craft and maybe catch the eyes of a patron.

What's left now is figuring out how the scene will be structured? I want an oomph, a shock. I don't want to start slow and build up speed, so I'll get straight into it.
He stood before the painting on the wall. This was it. His blood and sweat. The fruit of many months of labor. His last coin in the well.

A voice called out from behind him, "Marvelous. Truly marvelous."

Richard turned and his blood froze. A strange-looking man was intently staring at him. His empty unblinking eyes filled him with an unexplainable feeling of dread.

"You sir," He pointed at him, "Are a genius. Truly."

Richard failed to utter a reply.

The man grinned showing teeth from ear to ear. "Where are my manners?" He extended his hand and Richard found himself shaking it. "Farouq. A humble merchant, at your service."

I'll cut this scene here. It's good enough for this demonstration. This piece is about the artist. I want to keep the mysterious man, well, mysterious, so a limited POV from Richard is suitable.


Details
Details are the lifeblood of any scene, otherwise it is just a summary. I'll be using the cheatsheet as a reference.

The first bit of detail is about Richard.
  1. He's an artist
  2. He's broke
  3. He's desperate
  4. He's nervous
The first paragraph establishes 1 and 3.
He stood before the painting on the wall. This was it. His blood and sweat. The fruit of many months of labor. His last coin in the well.

Like scenes, paragraph have a purpose, one that's a tad more focused. Paragraphs have a main purpose. This paragraph introduces Richard as a painter and shows his desperation. There are two subjects here, Richard, obviously, and the painting. I have already established Richard's characteristics above, but what about his painting.

I can raise a few questions here. Sensory, first. What does the painting looks like? Perception. How does Richard feel about it? I'd like to keep it's appearance a mystery, mainly because I am lazy, and secondly because I can pretend it's a creative choice as it doesn't matter what the painting looked like, the entity wanted to approach Richard regardless. Small details can lead to big conclusions.
This was it. His blood and sweat. Months of his life hung on a sheet of linen covered in paint. Richard stood before his painting and stared.

There was very little that he was sure of. He wasn't sure where he'd sleep today or how he'd afford a meal, but he was certain of one thing: he hated this painting from his very core.

Every second spent on it, he despised. He had never finished a piece and it ate at him. He was no artist until he had a finished piece to his name. He had sworn to see the next complete, and now, he wished it was any but this.
Needs to be polished but good enough. The painting now has a negative connotation for Richard: a little bit of foreshadowing for what's to come.


Now I'd like to address Richard's mental state. He's nervous and anxious. He's in an unfamiliar environment looking for a possible buyer or patron. But what is this environment and how does it look, smell, and sound.
Richard took a deep breath and exhaled. The air smelled heavy of colone. He tried to ignore how narrow the corridor felt. How its white walls seemed to stretch endlessly, adorned by nothing but paintings separated by a few feet. The murmur of conversation came from his right; the gallery's entrance, far and away. He was buried deep, with noone but his work.
Not too shabby I think. I've addressed Richard, the painting, and the environment.


Now onto the entity. I want it to be:
- Confident
- Charming
- Eloquent

Currently, the entity's entrance is him suddenly speaking behind Richard.
A voice called out from behind him, "Marvelous. Truly marvelous."

But as I developed the scene, I've detailed that our MC is alone right now. Do I want this entity to appear out of thin air? No, not particularly. So, I'll turn this paragraph into a series of actions. First, it appears and heads towards him.
Footsteps broke the overbearing silence, tapping on the cold marble floor. A tall man, draped in a thick black coat wearing a tall top hat, walked towards him. He kept his hands in his pockets and his gaze fixated on him.

This is alright. I can describe him further if i wish when he gets closer. Now, I'd like to make the entity a little odd.
Richard watched, transfixed by the man's movement. He did not bend his knees. Legs straight, he raised one to his waist and brought it down forward, repeating the movement for the other behind, thumping on the ground as if he despised the very notion of walking.

After writing this and having him have a weirdly strong and wide gait, I want to change this
Footsteps broke the overbearing silence, tapping on the cold marble floor.
to something a little more forceful like this:
Loud footsteps broke the overbearing silence, echoing with each stomp on the cold marble floor.

It's all connected together and changes on the fly are quite common as the scene develops. Sometimes, the changes are drastic, sometimes they're not.

Now, for the interaction between the two. I still want to further describe the man as he got closer.
The man stopped before Richard and turned. Without a word, he raised his head and gazed at the painting on the wall.

Being this close to the man felt wrong. He was close enough for Richard to make out his features. He looked to be somewhere in his fifties. His face and scalp utterly hairless. His pupils dilated and nostrils flared as he continued to stare at his work. Richard swallowed a lump in his throat.

Minutes passed in silence before the strange man deemed it right to speak. "Marvelous." His mouth had barely moved yet his voice was clear, deep and vibrating. "Truly marvelous."

I'm not liking the next paragraph. Doesn't feel like it fits here. There's an eerie quality built already and having Richard instantly horrified kinda defeats the purpose. I'll continue the scene from here.
"You sir," He pointed at him, "Are a genius. Truly."

Richard failed to utter a reply.

The man grinned showing teeth from ear to ear. "Where are my manners?" He extended his hand and Richard found himself shaking it. "Farouq. A humble merchant, at your service."

This is the last section. Doesn't look too bad. Again, I'll simply add some details for flavour.
Slowly and mechanically, the man lowered his head until his eyes were leveled at him. "You, sir," He removed his hand from his pocket and pointed a bony finger at him, "Are a genius. Truly.

Richard failed to utter a reply.

He grinned from ear to ear, displaying a set of yellowy teeth. "Where are my manners?" He extended his hand and Richard found himself shaking it. "Farouq. A humble, humble, merchant, at your service."



The final result looks like this.

Loud footsteps broke the overbearing silence, echoing with each stomp on the cold marble floor. A tall man, draped in a thick black coat wearing a tall top hat, walked towards him. He kept his hands in his pockets and his gaze fixated on him.

Richard watched, transfixed by the man's movement. He did not bend his knees. Legs straight, he raised one to his waist and brought it down forward, repeating the movement for the other behind, thumping on the ground as if he despised the very notion of walking.

The man stopped before Richard and turned. Without a word, he raised his head and gazed at the painting on the wall.

Being this close to the man felt wrong. He was close enough for Richard to make out his features. He looked to be somewhere in his fifties. His face and scalp utterly hairless. His pupils dilated and nostrils flared as he continued to stare at his work. Richard swallowed a lump in his throat.

Minutes passed in silence before the strange man deemed it right to speak. "Marvelous." His mouth had barely moved yet his voice was clear, deep and vibrating. "Truly marvelous."

Slowly and mechanically, the man lowred his head until his eyes were leveled at him. "You, sir," He removed his hand from his pocket and pointed a bony finger at him, "Are a genius. Truly.

Richard failed to utter a reply.

He grinned from ear to ear, displaying a set of yellowy teeth. "Where are my manners?" He extended his hand and Richard found himself shaking it. "Farouq. A humble, humble, merchant, at your service."



  • I have the vision
A painter is in his studio. His studio is messy with incomplete paintings and spilled paint. He's sitting on a stool working on a painting. He's disheleved. Suddenly, a portal opens from his canvas and a mass of flesh slithers out of it.

This approach is a little tricky, especially if this scene is in the middle of a running novel. I have a vision for a really good scene but I'm not sure how to fit it.

I'll start by asking why is this painter important. Is he going to be a recurring character or is he in just this one scene?
Why was this portal opened and what are the possible consequences for it? Another question here would be how does this scene fit in the story.

Let's assume I have a fantasy medieval story. The MC is an adventurer who only accepts odd quests. Our MC is less of a fighter and more of an investigator. His latest quest is about... something missing. This something needs to link to our painter somehow.

Maybe there's been some disappearances happening, specifically targeting rich people. The victims are killed and mutilated and parts of their bodies are eaten. There's a great reward for finding the monster responsible. MC finds that the victims all have recently bought some paintings from the same painter. He traces him down to his home and is apprehended somehow.

This is a very convoluted solution but it's an interesting way of coming up with plot lines. The next steps are the same as the one above. I already have my scenario and setting. The POV will be from my MC. What's left is to outline the scene and creating a rough like above. Then following up by adding details and polishing the scene.


The quality of the article is not the greatest but it'll do for now as I don't have access to decent editing tools atm. Again, this is not a guide by any means but I'm hoping this was an interesting or useful read. Any questions are appreciated.
 
Last edited:

RepresentingWrath

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 7, 2020
Messages
13,552
Points
283
It's good. :blobsip:

The question I want to ask you, is how do you deal with conflict of the aforementioned properties and technical aspect, like choice of words. A small example to show what I mean.

A tall man, draped in a thick black coat wearing a tall top hat, walked towards him.

Tall man, tall hat. That's my personal quirk, I really hate repeating words. I can tolerate it in certain scenarios, when repetition adds to the scene, this one is not the case, and same is true for a lot of stuff I write. Do you simply don't care about it as much, and only fix glaring mistakes with editing, or you have some kind of established process for it?
 

greyblob

"Staff Memeber" pleasr
Joined
Feb 6, 2021
Messages
2,743
Points
153
It's good. :blobsip:

The question I want to ask you, is how do you deal with conflict of the aforementioned properties and technical aspect, like choice of words. A small example to show what I mean.

A tall man, draped in a thick black coat wearing a tall top hat, walked towards him.

Tall man, tall hat. That's my personal quirk, I really hate repeating words. I can tolerate it in certain scenarios, when repetition adds to the scene, this one is not the case, and same is true for a lot of stuff I write. Do you simply don't care about it as much, and only fix glaring mistakes with editing, or you have some kind of established process for it?
This has more to do with the technical writing process. I tried to avoid that as I am not very proficient in it.

But I run into these a lot. There's also repeating sentence structure and sentence beginnings. I handle all of that in the last and final step: the polishing phase. Though, I do try to keep these small details in mind as I write as to make my future self's life easier.

Coincidentally, the top hat bit was added later after I finished the paragraph. I'd change 'tall' to 'long' or something of the sorts.
 

LillyWhite

Active member
Joined
Mar 13, 2024
Messages
52
Points
33
This is very useful, can I use your post to create a writing guide for a writing application I'm making?
 

melchi

What is a custom title?
Joined
May 2, 2021
Messages
2,868
Points
153
This has more to do with the technical writing process. I tried to avoid that as I am not very proficient in it.

But I run into these a lot. There's also repeating sentence structure and sentence beginnings. I handle all of that in the last and final step: the polishing phase. Though, I do try to keep these small details in mind as I write as to make my future self's life easier.

Coincidentally, the top hat bit was added later after I finished the paragraph. I'd change 'tall' to 'long' or something of the sorts.
Tall top hat is a little redundant, thinks top hat could work just fine. Then Sailus won't be triggered.
 

RepresentingWrath

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 7, 2020
Messages
13,552
Points
283
Tall top hat is a little redundant, thinks top hat could work just fine. Then Sailus won't be triggered.
 

CharlesEBrown

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 23, 2024
Messages
4,572
Points
158
Tall top hat is a little redundant, thinks top hat could work just fine. Then Sailus won't be triggered.
Well, "traditionally" a top hat and a stove-pipe hat are the same thing except the latter is taller so a tall top hat may not be too redundant.
 
Top