Help me choose my writting style!

Not_A_Symphony

Picasso 2.0
Joined
Mar 15, 2021
Messages
181
Points
83
Hello everyone :meowsip:

I've been writting two different stories and I came to the conclusion that I have two opposite writting styles and I think it's better if I just stick to one, instead of being constantly shifting between them. I like them both and I don't exactly have friends that read so I don't really know what to do.
I'll post a small piece of the same story in the two different styles below (i just quickly rewrote version 2 in the "new style"), so please help me decide and give me some experienced input! :sweating_profusely:

“Ophelia is it true? Did you really try to curse your older sister?” After fifteen long and dreaded years with absolutely no communication, these were this man’s first words to his youngest child.

Not like I expected it to be any different.

My eyes voyaged through the clean, darkened room before spotting Amanda sitting gracefully on the bright red divan. Her lips curled as an overwhelming sense of pride emanated out of her stance.

“Is all of this really necessary?” Swiftly, I turned to the large and tall shelves filled with heavy books mostly regarding our kingdom’s history. “It seems to me as if the great Duke has already made up his mind.”

The moment our glances intertwined, his eyes sharpened, coldly glaring at me with easy to read thoughts. Once, my whole body would tremble with horror and fear at his feet, however, now, his thin figure belonged to no more than an exhausted man - clearly overused by the bliss of time and lacking any of the pressure and power it used to hold.

“Answer my question, Ophelia Criswell.”

After observing the carefully organized books on the wooden planks, my attention was drawn to one in specific. The hard yet bright yellow cover that embraced the thin paper sheets stood out among all its peers. My hands removed the item from the shelf as big letters read Nobility of Ashen Kingdom. I grinned towards the tall man sitting behind his large desk, his forehead filled with bumps, wrinkles born of his involuntary frowning.

“It seems elder sister mistook the library with her chambers... I simply reminded her of a lady’s etiquette.”

“How insolent! You dare educate your older sister!?” He yelled, venting out most of his pent-up frustration on the best puppet he owned: me.

“Ophelia is it true? Did you really try to curse your older sister?” After fifteen long and dreaded years, these were his first words to me.

Not like I expected it to be any different.

Even though his study had been carefully darkened to emphasize his authority, nothing could hide away my sister’s prideful glimmer. Her lips curled upwards like a half-moon, eyes sharpened like two steel blades, and her spine completely straight, shied away from the comfort of the red divan.

“Is all of this really necessary?” My attention turned to the tall shelves filled with history books, each one heavier than the other. “It seems to me as if the great Duke has already made up his mind.”

Our eyes intertwined, causing Alvin’s figure to lock itself in, hoping to appear more menacing than it truly was. Once, my heart would tremble with horror looking upon that disdainful, heartless glance, forcing my soul to turn into nothing but a shameful shard of glass, cowering at his feet. But things were different now. I could see the exhaustion on his body as the generous gift of ageless beauty slowly began losing its power, turning him into the shell of the man he once was.

Had he always looked like this? I couldn’t help but wonder if my memories deceived me.

“Answer my question, Ophelia Criswell.”

My stretched fingers pulled a bright yellow book from the layers of shelves, the only one that stood out like a sore thumb. Big, dark letters read ‘Nobility of Ashen Kingdom’.

“It seems elder sister mistook the library with her chambers... I simply reminded her of a lady’s etiquette.”

“How insolent! You dare educate your older sister!?” His screams echoed through the room as he poured all his frustration onto the easiest, most gullible target.

small note: I'm not a native english speaker so forgive me for any mistakes.
Thanks guys ! ~ :blobtaco:
 

AnonUnlimited

????????? (???/???)
Joined
Apr 18, 2022
Messages
4,572
Points
183
You are unforgiven.

Content and genre are also important when determining writing style.

Example 1 is slightly more formal.
Example 2 is slightly more personal.

Both don’t go all the way in style and so they’re too similar to really distinguish, but I felt example two was more to my liking.
 

greyblob

"Staff Memeber" pleasr
Joined
Feb 6, 2021
Messages
2,745
Points
153
 

Not_A_Symphony

Picasso 2.0
Joined
Mar 15, 2021
Messages
181
Points
83
You are unforgiven.

Content and genre are also important when determining writing style.

Example 1 is slightly more formal.
Example 2 is slightly more personal.

Both don’t go all the way in style and so they’re too similar to really distinguish, but I felt example two was more to my liking.
ahahah oh no, I am unforgiven, I shall burn in the author's burnout heat zone forever as a way to atonish for my grave sins! :sweating_profusely: :sweating_profusely: :sweating_profusely:
Thank you so much for your input! I think in the first one is more formal and a bit more lengthy in terms of descriptions and the second one more based off the characters feelings and such that's why I was a bit conflicted (of course the sample is also very small so it's hard to distinguish from there but I'd feel bad if I made you guys read a lot more :blob_shock:)

welp what is that supposed to mean? *panics in french* :blob_catflip:
 

Nolff

An attractive male of unspecified gender.
Joined
Aug 10, 2023
Messages
2,132
Points
153
ahahah oh no, I am unforgiven, I shall burn in the author's burnout heat zone forever as a way to atonish for my grave sins! :sweating_profusely: :sweating_profusely: :sweating_profusely:
Thank you so much for your input! I think in the first one is more formal and a bit more lengthy in terms of descriptions and the second one more based off the characters feelings and such that's why I was a bit conflicted (of course the sample is also very small so it's hard to distinguish from there but I'd feel bad if I made you guys read a lot more :blob_shock:)
Can't judge since I'm a fanfic writer. But hey, it's fun to read these two samples out loud in bri'ish accent.
welp what is that supposed to mean? *panics in french* :blob_catflip:
Transcript:

Ms. A: "The company asked us to see the difference between these two pictures."
Ms. A again: "They're the same picture."
 

CharlesEBrown

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 23, 2024
Messages
4,638
Points
158
I would consider the whole work (les plus millieu? been forty years since I took a French class...) rather than the fragment - what seems to work best for the overall product? From this snapshot, the second was a little more dramatic in feel so probably the better choice but ... this is just a fragment.
 

Not_A_Symphony

Picasso 2.0
Joined
Mar 15, 2021
Messages
181
Points
83
Search your heart, follow your soul.
My soul is torn :sweating_profusely:

you’re a Frenchmen?
Not at all :blobrofl: I'm portuguese

Can't judge since I'm a fanfic writer. But hey, it's fun to read these two samples out loud in bri'ish accent.

Transcript:

Ms. A: "The company asked us to see the difference between these two pictures."
Ms. A again: "They're the same picture."
I blame my english teacher for that. In my country they force us to learn british accent and if you use american they will deduct points off your final grade :blob_catflip:
Thank you for the clarification, I totally did not get the reference

I would consider the whole work (les plus millieu? been forty years since I took a French class...) rather than the fragment - what seems to work best for the overall product? From this snapshot, the second was a little more dramatic in feel so probably the better choice but ... this is just a fragment.
Yeah, I feel most of you are more inclined to the second one which tends to be more relatable I guess. I think I'll stay with the type of writting, thank you so much ! :blobtaco:

3

combine em
I don't even know how I'd start doing that, not going to lie... :blobrofl:

View attachment 31769
Hope this clears out the confusion
Thank you! It indeed does :blob_nom:
 

Kalliel

Grind, Future, A Beautiful Star
Joined
Aug 8, 2023
Messages
516
Points
133
They're the same to me. If I were an average reader, I wouldn't notice a thing if you switched between these two, so do what you prefer. Granted, there is not nearly enough data to judge fully.
 

Not_A_Symphony

Picasso 2.0
Joined
Mar 15, 2021
Messages
181
Points
83
They're the same to me. If I were an average reader, I wouldn't notice a thing if you switched between these two, so do what you prefer. Granted, there is not nearly enough data to judge fully.
Yeah I understand but it's like I said, I wanted some feedback without force feeding you into reading a big chunk of the novel to judge it :sweating_profusely: Thank you for your input regardless :blobsip:
 

AdOtherwise

Owl Who Reads · Hoot Hoot
Joined
Apr 8, 2023
Messages
120
Points
83
Hello everyone :meowsip:

I've been writting two different stories and I came to the conclusion that I have two opposite writting styles and I think it's better if I just stick to one, instead of being constantly shifting between them. I like them both and I don't exactly have friends that read so I don't really know what to do.
I'll post a small piece of the same story in the two different styles below (i just quickly rewrote version 2 in the "new style"), so please help me decide and give me some experienced input! :sweating_profusely:

“Ophelia is it true? Did you really try to curse your older sister?” After fifteen long and dreaded years with absolutely no communication, these were this man’s first words to his youngest child.

Not like I expected it to be any different.

My eyes voyaged through the clean, darkened room before spotting Amanda sitting gracefully on the bright red divan. Her lips curled as an overwhelming sense of pride emanated out of her stance.

“Is all of this really necessary?” Swiftly, I turned to the large and tall shelves filled with heavy books mostly regarding our kingdom’s history. “It seems to me as if the great Duke has already made up his mind.”

The moment our glances intertwined, his eyes sharpened, coldly glaring at me with easy to read thoughts. Once, my whole body would tremble with horror and fear at his feet, however, now, his thin figure belonged to no more than an exhausted man - clearly overused by the bliss of time and lacking any of the pressure and power it used to hold.

“Answer my question, Ophelia Criswell.”

After observing the carefully organized books on the wooden planks, my attention was drawn to one in specific. The hard yet bright yellow cover that embraced the thin paper sheets stood out among all its peers. My hands removed the item from the shelf as big letters read Nobility of Ashen Kingdom. I grinned towards the tall man sitting behind his large desk, his forehead filled with bumps, wrinkles born of his involuntary frowning.

“It seems elder sister mistook the library with her chambers... I simply reminded her of a lady’s etiquette.”

“How insolent! You dare educate your older sister!?” He yelled, venting out most of his pent-up frustration on the best puppet he owned: me.

“Ophelia is it true? Did you really try to curse your older sister?” After fifteen long and dreaded years, these were his first words to me.

Not like I expected it to be any different.

Even though his study had been carefully darkened to emphasize his authority, nothing could hide away my sister’s prideful glimmer. Her lips curled upwards like a half-moon, eyes sharpened like two steel blades, and her spine completely straight, shied away from the comfort of the red divan.

“Is all of this really necessary?” My attention turned to the tall shelves filled with history books, each one heavier than the other. “It seems to me as if the great Duke has already made up his mind.”

Our eyes intertwined, causing Alvin’s figure to lock itself in, hoping to appear more menacing than it truly was. Once, my heart would tremble with horror looking upon that disdainful, heartless glance, forcing my soul to turn into nothing but a shameful shard of glass, cowering at his feet. But things were different now. I could see the exhaustion on his body as the generous gift of ageless beauty slowly began losing its power, turning him into the shell of the man he once was.

Had he always looked like this? I couldn’t help but wonder if my memories deceived me.

“Answer my question, Ophelia Criswell.”

My stretched fingers pulled a bright yellow book from the layers of shelves, the only one that stood out like a sore thumb. Big, dark letters read ‘Nobility of Ashen Kingdom’.

“It seems elder sister mistook the library with her chambers... I simply reminded her of a lady’s etiquette.”

“How insolent! You dare educate your older sister!?” His screams echoed through the room as he poured all his frustration onto the easiest, most gullible target.

small note: I'm not a native english speaker so forgive me for any mistakes.
Thanks guys ! ~ :blobtaco:
2 is personal which I think will do better especially if you want your readers to feel your character's emotions.
 

MatchaChocolate69

? Your Valentine ?
Joined
Sep 25, 2023
Messages
859
Points
133
I prefer the first one because it conveys more coldness and clarity to me, which is what I expect from a character who wants to take control of their life again and seeks revenge by plotting.
 

HungrySheep

I like yuri
Joined
Jun 19, 2022
Messages
630
Points
133
Second reads better to me. Stuff like "My eyes voyaged" and "his forehead filled with bumps, wrinkles born of his involuntary frowning" sounds good to authors, but the majority of readers either don't seem to care or dislike it. You can just stick with simple things like "My attention turned to..." and "Our eyes intertwined..." for actions. If you must digress, I've found that describing or detailing atmosphere, mood, or personality is more effective as it lends the reader greater insight into the scene rather than focusing on something's/someone's appearance that isn't particularly relevant (unless it is, in which case feel free to digress).
 

Jocelyn_Uasal

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 30, 2024
Messages
233
Points
108
I think regardless of anything else, the two styles will eventually just combine into something new after enough writing
 

RepresentingDesire

Eye of Desire
Joined
Aug 9, 2023
Messages
1,346
Points
153
I prefer the first one because it conveys more coldness and clarity to me, which is what I expect from a character who wants to take control of their life again and seeks revenge by plotting.
I would argue that it would be the optimal attitude but not everyone can be that, but I think the writing style should reflect the personality an only the author knows that
 

Not_A_Symphony

Picasso 2.0
Joined
Mar 15, 2021
Messages
181
Points
83
I think the second would be better, she seems to me as more informal.
2 is personal which I think will do better especially if you want your readers to feel your character's emotions.
I prefer the first one because it conveys more coldness and clarity to me, which is what I expect from a character who wants to take control of their life again and seeks revenge by plotting.
Thank you so much for your input everyone! So far I think the majority of the people have a preference over the 2nd style which tends to be a bit more personal. It's interesting to see and I'd say I might just stick to that one in specific probably... :blob_frown:


Second reads better to me. Stuff like "My eyes voyaged" and "his forehead filled with bumps, wrinkles born of his involuntary frowning" sounds good to authors, but the majority of readers either don't seem to care or dislike it. You can just stick with simple things like "My attention turned to..." and "Our eyes intertwined..." for actions. If you must digress, I've found that describing or detailing atmosphere, mood, or personality is more effective as it lends the reader greater insight into the scene rather than focusing on something's/someone's appearance that isn't particularly relevant (unless it is, in which case feel free to digress).
That's a great point and I completely agree, focusing more on the environment and surroundings outside of the actions brings greater depth and immersion between the reader and the story, it's a great point. Thank you so much for your valuable input! :blob_aww:

I think regardless of anything else, the two styles will eventually just combine into something new after enough writing
Hmm maybe... well I think the 2nd style is an evolution of the 1st style but they are from completely different stories. The first one is from an historical society and older while the 2nd one I use is for a university romance/fantasy story... So I don't know :blob_popcorn_two:

I would argue that it would be the optimal attitude but not everyone can be that, but I think the writing style should reflect the personality an only the author knows that
Well it's true that my MC in this book is supposed to be very cold but at the same time I want people to read it and not feel bored nor confused you know? I don't know if I'm making any sense :blob_teary:
 
Top