Feedback for my first novel: The heir of truth

amirhosseinb1

Member
Joined
Mar 23, 2025
Messages
35
Points
8
If you have time and feel like trying something new, please read my novel.

I look forward to your valuable feedback.
 
Last edited:

SeaJay

Active member
Joined
Jun 24, 2024
Messages
71
Points
33
Your story and premise are interesting, and the prose is nice. However, you came here for advice, so here are some of my thoughts.
First of all, the title. It sounds cool and is high-flown. But. It's not engaging and is far too generic to draw me in.
Secondly, I have multiple problems with your synopsis. In essence: It's not good. And you abuse your : button, putting it into places where it makes no sense. And you need to condense some of your things and give me a very good reason why I want to read your story and engage with it in general, in the first place. Oh, and number your chapters. It just makes sense.
And why do you put "" where they don't belong?
I like your prose. It is good, but you rely too heavily on sounding cool and special and as if you have MC syndrome. Which is not good for a book.
For example, "Alder's whisper scraped like shards: "I know… This child has already read the world's ingratitude in my eyes. He refuses to draw breath in such a world." Her final scream died unborn. Her flushed face paled like molten wax, veins vanishing. The boy was born into silence heavier than death. When laid beside his mother—now swallowed by death's absolute silence—the infant suddenly wailed, a shattered lute's cry: not for life, but a lament for the grave.". There's good prose, then there's over the top. The dialogue sounds scripted, and the whole thing belongs in a play/movie, not a webnovel. I could delete half the words here, and it would have the same impact.
And the dialogue itself - make it sound natural, for god's sake! Personally, this is the worst part of your entire writing. Make it sound natural, like something you or me would say. It shouldn't sound like a soap opera or some gothic, edgy movie.
It's a good prose, I like it, but it needs some editing. Delete some unnecessary words, switch a few things around, replace some words, expand on some details, and get the reader emotionally invested in the characters, not the world.
That's it for my advice. But your story is good - you've gained a reader! Congrats!
Just... your title and synopsis. First impressions count, you know?
Anyway, just a little editing, and you're golden! Have a good day and good luck with your story!
 
Last edited:

amirhosseinb1

Member
Joined
Mar 23, 2025
Messages
35
Points
8
داستان و فرضیه شما جالب است و نثر آن هم خوب است. با این حال، شما برای مشاوره به اینجا آمده‌اید، بنابراین در اینجا برخی از نظرات من را می‌نویسم.
اول از همه، عنوان. به نظر جالب و پرطمطراق می‌آید. اما جذاب نیست و خیلی کلیشه‌ای است که من را جذب کند.
دوم اینکه، من با خلاصه داستان شما چندین مشکل دارم. در اصل: خوب نیست. و شما از دکمه‌ی : خود سوءاستفاده می‌کنید و آن را در جاهایی قرار می‌دهید که هیچ معنایی ندارد. و شما باید برخی از مطالب خود را خلاصه کنید و دلیل بسیار خوبی برای من بیاورید که چرا می‌خواهم داستان شما را بخوانم و به طور کلی با آن درگیر شوم، در وهله اول. اوه، و فصل‌های خود را شماره‌گذاری کنید. این کاملاً منطقی است.
و چرا جایی که جایشان نیست «» می‌گذارید؟
من نثر شما را دوست دارم. خوب است، اما شما بیش از حد به لحنی خاص و جذاب تکیه کرده‌اید و طوری نوشته‌اید که انگار سندرم MC دارید. که برای یک کتاب خوب نیست.
برای مثال، « نجوای آلدر مثل خرده‌های چوب خراشیده شد: «می‌دانم... این کودک قبلاً ناسپاس بودن دنیا را در چشمانم خوانده است. او در چنین دنیایی از نفس کشیدن امتناع می‌کند.» فریاد آخر او پیش از تولدش مُرد. صورت برافروخته‌اش مانند موم مذاب رنگ‌پریده و رگ‌هایش ناپدید شده بود. پسر در سکوتی سنگین‌تر از مرگ به دنیا آمد. وقتی کنار مادرش گذاشته شد - که اکنون در سکوت مطلق مرگ فرو رفته بود - نوزاد ناگهان ناله‌ای سر داد، فریادی شبیه عود شکسته: نه برای زندگی، بلکه مرثیه‌ای برای گور.» نثر خوبی دارد، اما اغراق‌آمیز هم هست. دیالوگ‌ها از پیش نوشته شده به نظر می‌رسند و کل ماجرا به یک نمایشنامه/فیلم تعلق دارد، نه یک رمان اینترنتی. می‌توانستم نیمی از کلمات را اینجا حذف کنم، و همین تأثیر را می‌داشت.
و خود دیالوگ - به خاطر خدا، طوری بنویس که طبیعی به نظر برسد! شخصاً، این بدترین بخش کل نوشته‌ی توست. طوری بنویس که طبیعی به نظر برسد، مثل چیزی که من یا تو می‌گوییم. نباید شبیه یک سریال آبکی یا یک فیلم گوتیک و تند و تیز باشد.
نثر خوبی است، من آن را دوست دارم، اما به کمی ویرایش نیاز دارد. برخی از کلمات غیرضروری را حذف کنید، چند چیز را جابجا کنید، برخی کلمات را جایگزین کنید، برخی جزئیات را گسترش دهید و کاری کنید که خواننده از نظر احساسی درگیر شخصیت‌ها شود، نه دنیای داستان.
نصیحت من همین بود. اما داستانت خوبه - یه خواننده پیدا کردی! تبریک میگم!
فقط... عنوان و خلاصه داستانت. برداشت اول مهمه، می‌دونی؟
به هر حال، فقط کمی ویرایش لازم است، و شما عالی هستید! روز خوبی داشته باشید و برای داستانتان آرزوی موفقیت دارم!
خیلی ممنون از راهنماییتون. این اولین رمانیه که مینویسم و بی تجربه هستم، اما سعی میکنم پیشرفت کنم.
 

PurpleAkemi16

New member
Joined
Aug 2, 2025
Messages
19
Points
3
HI I JUST FINISHED MY NEW SERIES. "NEKO GATO."
IT'S A COMEDY SERIES ABOUT TEENAGE NEKOS. THEY ONLY TAKE 8 MIN TO READ AND ARE SUPER CUTE!
Don't forget to like! Thx you!
 

amirhosseinb1

Member
Joined
Mar 23, 2025
Messages
35
Points
8
Chapter 25 has been uploaded and thank you for reading.
I am looking forward to your feedback and comments.??
Of course, I hope you'll tell me more about the problems in my novel because I want to fix them when I rewrite it.
 
Last edited:

amirhosseinb1

Member
Joined
Mar 23, 2025
Messages
35
Points
8
I apologize to everyone because the release time has been disrupted due to some problems that have arisen.
But now 27 chapters have been released, and I'm eagerly waiting to see your comments.
 

Natsummer

New member
Joined
Sep 1, 2025
Messages
8
Points
3
Sorry but first few lines, its written by ChatGPT or LLM... Its obvious.
 

amirhosseinb1

Member
Joined
Mar 23, 2025
Messages
35
Points
8
Sorry but first few lines, its written by ChatGPT or LLM... Its obvious.
Thank you for your comment, but I must say that I don't speak English and I'm translating my work, so yes, this problem has occurred, but in terms of the content of the work, there is no sign of artificial intelligence. You can look at all the parts.
You can see about this poetic and descriptive text in Persian literature and works such as Ferdowsi's Shahnameh and Saadi's Golestan.
Sorry but first few lines, its written by ChatGPT or LLM... Its obvious.
 

goth_dropping_in

Well-known member
Joined
May 28, 2024
Messages
44
Points
48
If you have time and feel like trying something new, please read my novel.

I look forward to your valuable feedback.
Your title is fine to good. Your synopsis is terrible; it fails to express any specifics, instead relying on ominous vagueness.

Opening your chapter, I'm immediately hit with very purple and over-wrought prose. It reads like you're trying to make it deeply dramatic and cool while having no idea how to do so, to be blunt; there's no direction to the writing, everything is given the same extreme amount of overwrought emphasis. It's clear you have no understanding of which parts of your work deserve intense description and which parts don't. You need to cut back this over-flowery description and try to focus on what's meaningful.

Also, "Aryan, child of purity"? Really? You're going to turn off a lot of readers with that name and description, because not only is it political, it's incredibly on the nose. Please reconsider.

Overall, it feels like you've served me a dish that's all seasoning and no meat. I'm turned off, rather than drawn in. Prune it back and it'll breathe much better.
 

amirhosseinb1

Member
Joined
Mar 23, 2025
Messages
35
Points
8
Your title is fine to good. Your synopsis is terrible; it fails to express any specifics, instead relying on ominous vagueness.

Opening your chapter, I'm immediately hit with very purple and over-wrought prose. It reads like you're trying to make it deeply dramatic and cool while having no idea how to do so, to be blunt; there's no direction to the writing, everything is given the same extreme amount of overwrought emphasis. It's clear you have no understanding of which parts of your work deserve intense description and which parts don't. You need to cut back this over-flowery description and try to focus on what's meaningful.

Also, "Aryan, child of purity"? Really? You're going to turn off a lot of readers with that name and description, because not only is it political, it's incredibly on the nose. Please reconsider.

Overall, it feels like you've served me a dish that's all seasoning and no meat. I'm turned off, rather than drawn in. Prune it back and it'll breathe much better.
Thank you for taking the time to share your feedback. I appreciate every reader's perspective as it helps me see different viewpoints.

Regarding the prose: The stylistic choice is intentional and part of my personal narrative style for this epic fantasy genre. I use detailed descriptions to enrich the world-building and create a specific atmosphere that matches the story's tragic and epic tone. I understand that preferences vary greatly in this area, and I am always open to constructive feedback on pacing and description.

Regarding the name "Aryan": This name has deep roots in Persian (Farsi) language and ancient Iranian culture, meaning "noble" or "pure of spirit." Its use here is solely based on its meaning and cultural significance, entirely within that context.

I appreciate your candor. I'm always open to detailed and constructive critique that can help me refine my work.
 

CharlesEBrown

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 23, 2024
Messages
4,748
Points
158
Regarding the name "Aryan": This name has deep roots in Persian (Farsi) language and ancient Iranian culture, meaning "noble" or "pure of spirit." Its use here is solely based on its meaning and cultural significance, entirely within that context.
I've seen some texts that, prior to WWII, used this as a name, but were edited after to be Arjan.

The term migrated to Europe through the Slavic countries and the meaning changed significantly, at least twice (once it meant "invader" or "foreigner"!) over the centuries.
 

amirhosseinb1

Member
Joined
Mar 23, 2025
Messages
35
Points
8
I've seen some texts that, prior to WWII, used this as a name, but were edited after to be Arjan.

The term migrated to Europe through the Slavic countries and the meaning changed significantly, at least twice (once it meant "invader" or "foreigner"!) over the centuries.
Thank you for pointing out this historical nuance. I am fully aware of the complex journey of this word through various languages and cultures, and the negative connotations it acquired in a specific period.


However, in my fictional world, this name has returned to its ancient and original root in the Persian language. Here, "Aryan" is not a label, but an authentic name that carries the meaning of "nobleman," "genuine," and "Iranian." For my character, this name symbolizes an identity that he seeks to discover and rebuild; an identity rooted in an ancient civilization and a profound philosophy.


One of my goals as a writer is to reclaim this word and restore its original and beautiful meaning to fictional literature. I hope my readers will see this name in the light of the culture and world-building of this work.
 

CharlesEBrown

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 23, 2024
Messages
4,748
Points
158
Thank you for pointing out this historical nuance. I am fully aware of the complex journey of this word through various languages and cultures, and the negative connotations it acquired in a specific period.


However, in my fictional world, this name has returned to its ancient and original root in the Persian language. Here, "Aryan" is not a label, but an authentic name that carries the meaning of "nobleman," "genuine," and "Iranian." For my character, this name symbolizes an identity that he seeks to discover and rebuild; an identity rooted in an ancient civilization and a profound philosophy.


One of my goals as a writer is to reclaim this word and restore its original and beautiful meaning to fictional literature. I hope my readers will see this name in the light of the culture and world-building of this work.
I would suggest adding something like your comment quoted above to either an Author's Note before the character first appears, or as a "warning" in the synopsis/blurb then so people can go in without their modern preconceptions (or back out before hitting that "wall," as their tastes dictate).
 

amirhosseinb1

Member
Joined
Mar 23, 2025
Messages
35
Points
8
I would suggest adding something like your comment quoted above to either an Author's Note before the character first appears, or as a "warning" in the synopsis/blurb then so people can go in without their modern preconceptions (or back out before hitting that "wall," as their tastes dictate).
Okay, thank you for your suggestion.
 

amirhosseinb1

Member
Joined
Mar 23, 2025
Messages
35
Points
8
I'm sorry for the delay. Due to moving and relocation, I didn't have enough time and couldn't concentrate properly. I hope you enjoy it.
 
Top