Battle of Megacity-0 complete! Feedback wanted

MC-Stories

The Wandering Dragon Storyteller
Joined
Dec 2, 2025
Messages
118
Points
28
Battle of Megacity-0 is now complete, your feedback would be greatly appreciated, this collection of short stories explain the hardships that people of this once thriving city went through during this violent time in their lives, and how all of it could have been avoided.....
 

Nolff

An attractive male of unspecified gender.
Joined
Aug 10, 2023
Messages
2,108
Points
153
Battle of Megacity-0 is now complete, your feedback would be greatly appreciated, this collection of short stories explain the hardships that people of this once thriving city went through during this violent time in their lives, and how all of it could have been avoided.....
What the f*ck is this notepad format chaps?

You expect me to drag my cursor? Please, make this more convenient.
 

L1aei

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 19, 2025
Messages
1,047
Points
113
Battle of Megacity-0 is now complete, your feedback would be greatly appreciated, this collection of short stories explain the hardships that people of this once thriving city went through during this violent time in their lives, and how all of it could have been avoided.....

Alright, first? Respect. It's deserved to you because you're not being timid in the slightest; you commit. Every chapter has had choices made, followed through with them, and the best part is that they have consequences. That? That separates you from an amateur who drafts action scenes with nothing happening as an aftermath.

As for the formatting problem here? Meh. I read it without an issue. But you do have a control issue and it repeats throughout the novel.

So, for example, you've got quite a few spelling mistakes. I dunno, but maybe the keys on your keyboard are being a little stuck or something because these mistakes look like you were typing too fast for the keys to respond in time; like "i" instead of it being in uppercase, dicipline, canbalism, seccond, strengh, and some others. Also, there's quite a few commas being littered everywhere.

Now, those I don't mind when I get what you're conveying. I got the vision in my head. But other readers may lose their boner over this.

What does become an issue is when the tenses get mixed up. That becomes a problem because I can no longer tell if this happened already or if it is going on now. See what I mean?

You write fast. That's what I am getting from these mistakes. Good news is that they are extremely easy to go back, proofread it, and make those amends. :blobthumbsup:

Now for the not so easy stuff. You fall under the "telling" and not the "showing" style of writing. Like I can pick a few out of there to give you an example: "I was horrified", "It was genocide", "I felt my rage building", "I failed", or "It was madness" and such.

Remember consequences? Stories also need impact before we see the results. Something like solid sensory details, a physical reaction, and some space to give us a real comparison if it is a scene that we will never experience in real life. Okay, that last one might be difficult to understand, so let me explain a little: if we go back to the Vietnam War and see an American plane carpet the jungle in napalm, we're going to know it's a fire, but we need something to compare it with like how that shit is like sticky mud that burns, that can't be simply brushed off with a swipe of our hands because then our own limbs catch on fire too. The horror of such a chemical weapon should be presented as an experience, so immerse us.

Actually, speaking of immersion, I'm noticing a pattern with each chapter. I'm not gonna say that's bad, but it is predictable when you have the narration at the beginning, the explanation of the chaos, then you proceed to have something horrific pop out at us, we get something violent or tragic in response, and then it ends on a moral note.

The reason I am bringing that up is because when something becomes predictable, something we can foresee, it loses that thrill. You know, when we grip the arms of our chairs when reading what will happen next? That sort of deal.

Oh... uh, we also have a small bit of tonal whiplash too. Like, panther kills a father rather brutally, but follows after a shower and a decent nap... huh? I get that's supposed to show how common stuff like that is, but it's rather jarring in the wrong way. You're going for tragedy here, but it feels like this stuff resolves itself too... too cleanly? Where's the mess?

Consequences should be messy. You have them, just that they are currently picture perfect.

Speaking of picture perfect, what is an Awakened? And why did cannibalism escalate so quickly? Oh, also, what did trigger the riots? I get there was some serious discrimination going on, but where did that come from too? Let's get some backstories that'll build the foundation of these incidents because, right now, it just gives me the message that society collapsed because people are evil.

That's a thesis, not a setting.

As for everything else? Great! Well, at least in concept. You still need to go back and proofread it all to transform them into an epic; it's not that far off from being one. :blob_okay:

We got the point of views of these chapters and the concepts of them are awesome. Like, we get the morals and they are consistent. Things such as the church's cannibalism, the panther awakening, the pilot tackling Marcus mid-air, and the bartender saving that poor one-armed girl; those are an instinct we can tap into. It's like a raw muscle where we don't have to be conscious to comprehend, we feel it.

Uh, but I do have to say that your epilogue is... dude, I fall asleep on lectures, so I am glad that was the last chapter. :sweat_smile:
 

Nolff

An attractive male of unspecified gender.
Joined
Aug 10, 2023
Messages
2,108
Points
153
Alright, first? Respect. It's deserved to you because you're not being timid in the slightest; you commit. Every chapter has had choices made, followed through with them, and the best part is that they have consequences. That? That separates you from an amateur who drafts action scenes with nothing happening as an aftermath.

As for the formatting problem here? Meh. I read it without an issue. But you do have a control issue and it repeats throughout the novel.

So, for example, you've got quite a few spelling mistakes. I dunno, but maybe the keys on your keyboard are being a little stuck or something because these mistakes look like you were typing too fast for the keys to respond in time; like "i" instead of it being in uppercase, dicipline, canbalism, seccond, strengh, and some others. Also, there's quite a few commas being littered everywhere.

Now, those I don't mind when I get what you're conveying. I got the vision in my head. But other readers may lose their boner over this.

What does become an issue is when the tenses get mixed up. That becomes a problem because I can no longer tell if this happened already or if it is going on now. See what I mean?

You write fast. That's what I am getting from these mistakes. Good news is that they are extremely easy to go back, proofread it, and make those amends. :blobthumbsup:

Now for the not so easy stuff. You fall under the "telling" and not the "showing" style of writing. Like I can pick a few out of there to give you an example: "I was horrified", "It was genocide", "I felt my rage building", "I failed", or "It was madness" and such.

Remember consequences? Stories also need impact before we see the results. Something like solid sensory details, a physical reaction, and some space to give us a real comparison if it is a scene that we will never experience in real life. Okay, that last one might be difficult to understand, so let me explain a little: if we go back to the Vietnam War and see an American plane carpet the jungle in napalm, we're going to know it's a fire, but we need something to compare it with like how that shit is like sticky mud that burns, that can't be simply brushed off with a swipe of our hands because then our own limbs catch on fire too. The horror of such a chemical weapon should be presented as an experience, so immerse us.

Actually, speaking of immersion, I'm noticing a pattern with each chapter. I'm not gonna say that's bad, but it is predictable when you have the narration at the beginning, the explanation of the chaos, then you proceed to have something horrific pop out at us, we get something violent or tragic in response, and then it ends on a moral note.

The reason I am bringing that up is because when something becomes predictable, something we can foresee, it loses that thrill. You know, when we grip the arms of our chairs when reading what will happen next? That sort of deal.

Oh... uh, we also have a small bit of tonal whiplash too. Like, panther kills a father rather brutally, but follows after a shower and a decent nap... huh? I get that's supposed to show how common stuff like that is, but it's rather jarring in the wrong way. You're going for tragedy here, but it feels like this stuff resolves itself too... too cleanly? Where's the mess?

Consequences should be messy. You have them, just that they are currently picture perfect.

Speaking of picture perfect, what is an Awakened? And why did cannibalism escalate so quickly? Oh, also, what did trigger the riots? I get there was some serious discrimination going on, but where did that come from too? Let's get some backstories that'll build the foundation of these incidents because, right now, it just gives me the message that society collapsed because people are evil.

That's a thesis, not a setting.

As for everything else? Great! Well, at least in concept. You still need to go back and proofread it all to transform them into an epic; it's not that far off from being one. :blob_okay:

We got the point of views of these chapters and the concepts of them are awesome. Like, we get the morals and they are consistent. Things such as the church's cannibalism, the panther awakening, the pilot tackling Marcus mid-air, and the bartender saving that poor one-armed girl; those are an instinct we can tap into. It's like a raw muscle where we don't have to be conscious to comprehend, we feel it.

Uh, but I do have to say that your epilogue is... dude, I fall asleep on lectures, so I am glad that was the last chapter. :sweat_smile:
@MC-Stories The MVP right here.
 

MC-Stories

The Wandering Dragon Storyteller
Joined
Dec 2, 2025
Messages
118
Points
28
Alright, first? Respect. It's deserved to you because you're not being timid in the slightest; you commit. Every chapter has had choices made, followed through with them, and the best part is that they have consequences. That? That separates you from an amateur who drafts action scenes with nothing happening as an aftermath.

As for the formatting problem here? Meh. I read it without an issue. But you do have a control issue and it repeats throughout the novel.

So, for example, you've got quite a few spelling mistakes. I dunno, but maybe the keys on your keyboard are being a little stuck or something because these mistakes look like you were typing too fast for the keys to respond in time; like "i" instead of it being in uppercase, dicipline, canbalism, seccond, strengh, and some others. Also, there's quite a few commas being littered everywhere.

Now, those I don't mind when I get what you're conveying. I got the vision in my head. But other readers may lose their boner over this.

What does become an issue is when the tenses get mixed up. That becomes a problem because I can no longer tell if this happened already or if it is going on now. See what I mean?

You write fast. That's what I am getting from these mistakes. Good news is that they are extremely easy to go back, proofread it, and make those amends. :blobthumbsup:

Now for the not so easy stuff. You fall under the "telling" and not the "showing" style of writing. Like I can pick a few out of there to give you an example: "I was horrified", "It was genocide", "I felt my rage building", "I failed", or "It was madness" and such.

Remember consequences? Stories also need impact before we see the results. Something like solid sensory details, a physical reaction, and some space to give us a real comparison if it is a scene that we will never experience in real life. Okay, that last one might be difficult to understand, so let me explain a little: if we go back to the Vietnam War and see an American plane carpet the jungle in napalm, we're going to know it's a fire, but we need something to compare it with like how that shit is like sticky mud that burns, that can't be simply brushed off with a swipe of our hands because then our own limbs catch on fire too. The horror of such a chemical weapon should be presented as an experience, so immerse us.

Actually, speaking of immersion, I'm noticing a pattern with each chapter. I'm not gonna say that's bad, but it is predictable when you have the narration at the beginning, the explanation of the chaos, then you proceed to have something horrific pop out at us, we get something violent or tragic in response, and then it ends on a moral note.

The reason I am bringing that up is because when something becomes predictable, something we can foresee, it loses that thrill. You know, when we grip the arms of our chairs when reading what will happen next? That sort of deal.

Oh... uh, we also have a small bit of tonal whiplash too. Like, panther kills a father rather brutally, but follows after a shower and a decent nap... huh? I get that's supposed to show how common stuff like that is, but it's rather jarring in the wrong way. You're going for tragedy here, but it feels like this stuff resolves itself too... too cleanly? Where's the mess?

Consequences should be messy. You have them, just that they are currently picture perfect.

Speaking of picture perfect, what is an Awakened? And why did cannibalism escalate so quickly? Oh, also, what did trigger the riots? I get there was some serious discrimination going on, but where did that come from too? Let's get some backstories that'll build the foundation of these incidents because, right now, it just gives me the message that society collapsed because people are evil.

That's a thesis, not a setting.

As for everything else? Great! Well, at least in concept. You still need to go back and proofread it all to transform them into an epic; it's not that far off from being one. :blob_okay:

We got the point of views of these chapters and the concepts of them are awesome. Like, we get the morals and they are consistent. Things such as the church's cannibalism, the panther awakening, the pilot tackling Marcus mid-air, and the bartender saving that poor one-armed girl; those are an instinct we can tap into. It's like a raw muscle where we don't have to be conscious to comprehend, we feel it.

Uh, but I do have to say that your epilogue is... dude, I fall asleep on lectures, so I am glad that was the last chapter. :sweat_smile:
This explains all of the event that led up to the Battle Of Megacity-0
 

FRWriter

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 3, 2024
Messages
527
Points
108
Feedback is kinda useless. You did that for your other stories as well, and even after pointing out insane mistakes, like spelling errors in the TITLE of the book, you didn't even bother to correct them. Your stories are still mispelled, EPILOGUE is still written as EPILOUGE. GENESIS is still written as GENISIS. BEGINNING is still written as BEGINING.

Honestly, asking for feedback and then doing nothing with it is kinda disrespectful, so you have forever lost me there. I think it's extremely rude to act like you want feedback and want to improve and hear people's opinions, then get a ton of helpful suggestions, and then you simply ignore them all. Not even bothering to correct your obviously wrong titles is just the height of laziness and, frankly, disrespectful to those who pointed out these mistakes.

Call me a sceptic, but I doubt @L1aei feedback, which probably took a shitton of time to read and then point out in such a clear way, will have any effect. You won't change a thing. You won't correct anything. Instead, you will ask more and more people to read, hoping for a different outcome that simply won't happen. You do not even want feedback. You want praise and more readers.

I'm done here, and I won't comment on these posts anymore, but I really think it's a scummy thing to do.
 
Last edited:

MC-Stories

The Wandering Dragon Storyteller
Joined
Dec 2, 2025
Messages
118
Points
28
Feedback is kinda useless. You did that for your other stories as well, and even after pointing out insane mistakes, like spelling errors in the TITLE of the book, you didn't even bother to correct them. Your stories are still mispelled, EPILOGUE is still written as EPILOUGE. GENESIS is still written as GENISIS. BEGINNING is still written as BEGINING.

Honestly, asking for feedback and then doing nothing with it is kinda disrespectful, so you have forever lost me there. I think it's extremely rude to act like you want feedback and want to improve and hear people's opinions, then get a ton of helpful suggestions, and then you simply ignore them all. Not even bothering to correct your obviously wrong titles is just the height if lazyness and frankly disrespect to those who pointed out these mistakes.

Call me a sceptic, but I doubt @L1aei feedback, which probably took a shitton of time to read and then point out in such a clear way, will have any effect. You won't change a thing. You won't correct anything. Instead, you will ask more and more people to read, hoping for a different outcome that simply won't happen. You do not even want feedback. You want praise and more readers.

I'm done here, and I won't comment on these posts anymore, but I really think it's a scummy thing to do.
Ok, just because I didn't change anything, doesn't mean i don't care about others opinions, i CAN'T make any changes to the writing format, i've tried, god knows I tried, and what you just said now isn't helping my self esteem, and my short attention span won't allow me to just start over

This is why i ignore YOU, not everyone else...so if you don't wanna post here, fine, i won't force you, there are dozens of people who will understand my situation
 

MC-Stories

The Wandering Dragon Storyteller
Joined
Dec 2, 2025
Messages
118
Points
28
Explain why not. Be specific.
I have tried various ways to make my text easier to digest, nothing worked, and SH's tools were difficult for my short attention span to handle, also, the last time i downloaded a free writing program, it gave my laptop a virus, so i'm very wary of that.

All and all, i thought people would look past the formatting issues and I find an amazing story, but thanks to @FRWriter , i don't ever think that is gonna happen, i hope he's happy
 

FRWriter

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 3, 2024
Messages
527
Points
108
I have tried various ways to make my text easier to digest, nothing worked, and SH's tools were difficult for my short attention span to handle, also, the last time i downloaded a free writing program, it gave my laptop a virus, so i'm very wary of that.

All and all, i thought people would look past the formatting issues and I find an amazing story, but thanks to @FRWriter , i don't ever think that is gonna happen, i hope he's happy

I said I am done, but if you keep name-calling me and hilariously blaming me for all kinds of stuff, I will respond.

I never mentioned your format. It sucks, without a doubt, but what I was talking about is that people tell you specific mistakes you made, not subjective opinions, mind you, and your unwillingness to correct them. It's HILARIOUS that I am now to blame for... whatever, I don't even know. As for "writing tool". You just need to copy and paste your chapters into the site. It couldn't be simpler. Frankly, it's a task I could give to a kindergarten student, but again, I DIDN'T EVEN TALK ABOUT IT.

I merely mentioned you MISSPELLING your BOOK TITLES and CHAPTER TITLES, which numerous people pointed out. In your old and previous threads, you've been corrected by more than a couple of people. It takes like 30 seconds to correct these mistakes, yet you didn't bother with it.

I have no problem with your story, I have no problem with you. I wish you all the best of luck with your stories.

I have a problem with you asking for feedback, then receiving feedback from many people who take the time to read your work, and then simply deciding to ignore it, not even bothering to correct your book title.

In any case, just block me, and I'll promise I will ignore your threads as well. I just stated that I am tired of you begging for feedback and then doing absolutely nothing with it, and I think I am entitled to that opinion. If you can't stand the heat, get out of the kitchen (Don't ask for feedback if you only want to hear compliments).
 
Last edited:

MC-Stories

The Wandering Dragon Storyteller
Joined
Dec 2, 2025
Messages
118
Points
28
I said I am done, but if you keep name-calling me and blaming me for all kinds of stuff, I will respond.

I never mentioned your format. It sucks, without a doubt, but what I was talking about is that people tell you things, not subjective opinions, but objective mistakes, mind you.

I merely mentioned you MISSPELLING your BOOK TITLES and CHAPTER TITLES. In your old and previous threads, you've been corrected by more than a couple of people. It takes like 30 seconds to change these mistakes, yet you didn't bother with
I never. Called you anything!
 

Hans.Trondheim

Till Seger!
Joined
Jan 22, 2021
Messages
1,918
Points
153
I never. Called you anything!
You tagged him, so...

Any case, if this can help, if you are having formatting issues, you can try fixing them via other websites. It doesn't necessary to post them there, just hit the save button for future use.

For example, I have an account in Wattpad, where I copy-paste my story. Microsoft Word's formatting becomes messy in ScribbleHub UI, so I have to go to Wattpad first, then copy the story from there, before posting on ScribbleHub main site.

I also have one in Inkitt. I don't post there, but I use their UI to format and divide my manuscript into chapters.
 

MC-Stories

The Wandering Dragon Storyteller
Joined
Dec 2, 2025
Messages
118
Points
28
fuck...man i'm stupid, thank you for clearing that up, but still, he stated that I kept name calling him, when I have only done it once
You tagged him, so...

Any case, if this can help, if you are having formatting issues, you can try fixing them via other websites. It doesn't necessary to post them there, just hit the save button for future use.

For example, I have an account in Wattpad, where I copy-paste my story. Microsoft Word's formatting becomes messy in ScribbleHub UI, so I have to go to Wattpad first, then copy the story from there, before posting on ScribbleHub main site.

I also have one in Inkitt. I don't post there, but I use their UI to format and divide my manuscript into chapters.
Thanks, i will take that into consideration....i did try wattpad, but it's tools were difficult to use, SH was the only site i could easily access
 

Hans.Trondheim

Till Seger!
Joined
Jan 22, 2021
Messages
1,918
Points
153
fuck...man i'm stupid, thank you for clearing that up, but still, he stated that I kept name calling him, when I have only done it once
We all are, sometimes or when new. Don't feel so bad about it.

Like last time I raised hell at our school because I thought someone carnapped my motorcycle...only to find out I forgot parking it somewhere. ???
Thanks, i will take that into consideration....i did try wattpad, but it's tools were difficult to use, SH was the only site i could easily access
If you need some clarifications, feel free to tag and ask me. I can't be messaged in my profile now because I'm supposed to isolate myself (did not happen ?) while writing my novel.
 

Jaymi

Time Traveling Idol
Joined
Apr 27, 2023
Messages
177
Points
83
I have tried various ways to make my text easier to digest, nothing worked, and SH's tools were difficult for my short attention span to handle, also, the last time i downloaded a free writing program, it gave my laptop a virus, so i'm very wary of that.

All and all, i thought people would look past the formatting issues and I find an amazing story, but thanks to @FRWriter , i don't ever think that is gonna happen, i hope he's happy
Dunno if it helps but i use Notion. It’s free and in my opinion one of the best writing apps for any creative, i use it for literally everything
 
Top