Are fanfics that do not have an isekai'd protagonist hard to find?

OP1000

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 1, 2021
Messages
387
Points
83
Hello!!!!
Do you guys feel like it is a very difficult task to find a good fanfic where the original character is a character that is neither reincarnated nor a transmigrated character? How often are you able to find fanfics written in this manner?
 

galaxy123

Active member
Joined
May 7, 2022
Messages
22
Points
43
Here, pretty rare:
 

NotaNuffian

This does spark joy.
Joined
Nov 26, 2019
Messages
5,315
Points
233
... the point of a SI is for the writer/ reader to insert themselves into said role and this is in CN as well, but they often just intro the MC as someone from our world that gets yeeted into the fanfic, thereby creating a link of "oh, that could be me".

What is the point of an OG character then if he is not the proxy?

You trying to make a butterfly effect where this random character not from the original cast suddenly takes the spotlight? That feels even weirder.
 

ArcadiaBlade

I'm a Lazy Writer, So What?
Joined
Dec 23, 2018
Messages
967
Points
133
I only know 3 fanfics, one is completed with a sequel that isn't. And there are two which isn't completed. So I can't recommend them to you since the author might have good ideas but kinda infamous for not completing his novels.
 

Itsary

Active member
Joined
Aug 15, 2019
Messages
2
Points
43
I think i remember reding it in different sites, naruto fanfic
- fmc twin sister of sakura that useful
- Naruto that smart and have dark personality
- fmc with Nara blood and uchiha eyes
I forgot the sites.
 
Last edited:

ACertainPassingUser

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 12, 2022
Messages
1,103
Points
153
It was the other way around, Fanfic with Self Insert protagonist is usually hard to find. And finding the ones that didn't suck is even harder.

Fanfic is alterations or fanmade story of official story by some fan that want to change some thing inside the story.

Like for example, when someone write Harry Potter fanfic, you can expect some sorry like :
"Harry Potter is having gay love with Snape and Malfoy, the whole character have painted hair and tatto like ghettos, LGBT rainbow flag is flying everywhere inside castle, painting in the wall is cursing the name JK Rowling, Teachers are doing Fortnite dance, Professor Werewolf is marrying Prince of Azkaban, Hermonie is going acceleration course and will graduate next month, Ron and friends is forgotten (cause writer thinks Ron is stupid even tho he's just a kid), and Hogwarts headmaster is not Dumbledore (it's Voldemort btw)."

That's fanfiction, a fan made story that based on already existing story.

Sometimes when they want to be the "modern person" into the story and they getting along with Main character and friends as buddy while being powerful and knows everything guy. It's Self Insert, and usually suck because they just want to be strong inside their own story.

It's only when the Isekai Boom started, with SAO and others, that many people started writing High quality story of people getting sent into the fantasy world

But the trend of "reincarnated into story" only boomed after "My Next Life as a Villainess: All Routes Lead to Doom!"

1677852487067.jpg



This is the core of stories about people getting transported into novels, Especially as villain.

Its the reason why all self insert fanfiction suddenly became far more popular to the point of overwhelming normal non self insert fanfiction.
 

Itsary

Active member
Joined
Aug 15, 2019
Messages
2
Points
43
Hey, i found sites with many fanfiction with less isekai character. Fanfiction.net
You just need to find a genre and/or character that suits your taste.
 

Jemini

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 27, 2019
Messages
2,037
Points
153
People gotta self insert somehow.
I find this really quite silly. Here I've only written a very small number of fan fics between my wider body of work. One was a cross-over fan-fic with characters from two pre-existing franchises that I just wanted to see cross over, and I used established world-hopping mechanics from one of the involved series in order to justify it.

The other was a continuation of a completed story people just wanted to see more of, because an author-provided alter-world story was actually quite prime for allowing this to happen. Neither one of these stories involved a single original character created by me. Both involved 100% characters from the existing stories portrayed as faithfully as I could.

I might add, in the latter case especially, I got quite a few impressed comments about how it really felt like they were reading the original from the original author and could hardly tell it was a fan-fic.

In a way, this is actually a carrying on of the original tradition of fan-fiction. Some of the first fan-fiction ever written was actually for the purpose of continuing the Sherlock Holmes stories after Conan Doyle had killed off the title character. Lots of this fan fiction actually offered means by which Holmes would survive his fall of Reinbach falls. And, interestingly enough, all these fan-fics actually inspired the author and had reportedly even used the suggestion from one of the fan-fics on how Holmes survives, and used it to pick up the story again himself. A lot of those Sherlock Holmes fan-fics from back in the day really did look exactly like something from the original author.

You could also argue for some of the King Aurthur content being fan-fiction as well, considering it's not all written by Chaucer and just picks up the same story Chaucer started, although a lot of Authurian scholars actually consider all the works cannon regardless of the fact that it's by several different authors.

But, seriously, my stance is that there's a lot of fan fiction writers out there today who really need to get their heads in the game.
 

Leti

Joined
Jun 17, 2020
Messages
757
Points
133
Hello!!!!
Do you guys feel like it is a very difficult task to find a good fanfic where the original character is a character that is neither reincarnated nor a transmigrated character? How often are you able to find fanfics written in this manner?
It is a very difficult task to find a good fanfic where the original character is a character that is neither reincarnated nor a transmigrated character because most people dislike OCs.
 

Lloyd

Funny Guy :)
Joined
Jun 2, 2020
Messages
2,538
Points
153
I find this really quite silly. Here I've only written a very small number of fan fics between my wider body of work. One was a cross-over fan-fic with characters from two pre-existing franchises that I just wanted to see cross over, and I used established world-hopping mechanics from one of the involved series in order to justify it.

The other was a continuation of a completed story people just wanted to see more of, because an author-provided alter-world story was actually quite prime for allowing this to happen. Neither one of these stories involved a single original character created by me. Both involved 100% characters from the existing stories portrayed as faithfully as I could.

I might add, in the latter case especially, I got quite a few impressed comments about how it really felt like they were reading the original from the original author and could hardly tell it was a fan-fic.

In a way, this is actually a carrying on of the original tradition of fan-fiction. Some of the first fan-fiction ever written was actually for the purpose of continuing the Sherlock Holmes stories after Conan Doyle had killed off the title character. Lots of this fan fiction actually offered means by which Holmes would survive his fall of Reinbach falls. And, interestingly enough, all these fan-fics actually inspired the author and had reportedly even used the suggestion from one of the fan-fics on how Holmes survives, and used it to pick up the story again himself. A lot of those Sherlock Holmes fan-fics from back in the day really did look exactly like something from the original author.

You could also argue for some of the King Aurthur content being fan-fiction as well, considering it's not all written by Chaucer and just picks up the same story Chaucer started, although a lot of Authurian scholars actually consider all the works cannon regardless of the fact that it's by several different authors.

But, seriously, my stance is that there's a lot of fan fiction writers out there today who really need to get their heads in the game.
 
Top