Advice about a point.

ArlindoFrancisco

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 18, 2024
Messages
89
Points
48
I didn't want to ask for writing tips because maybe some people would think I was promoting my story so better to post here.

To put it bluntly, my story is about a guy that has memories of the past but just the memories are not reincarnation; those memories come from a hero that was reincarnated from earth and all that. not really that complex.

For the hero in the past, he could use runes to build or improve devices or enchant armor and stuff, for example, Magictech, which he used for his party and himself sometimes and never bothered to teach anyone like any overpower protagonist would. My MC has that as his power; that is the difference; now he needed to give permission to people so that they could use his devices. In the beginning of the story, he didn't even think about teaching to anyone, as everything was still new and he needed to learn how it works. Again, he is not the hero himself, just the memories, and it is not like the hero even tried to build the things he was trying to.

Instead of saying it out loud, I hinted at putting the MC showing a device to a blacksmith who was his only friend and at first he could not use it, but then he said in a way in the middle of the conversation something like "See, now you can use it" while holding the hand of the blacksmith and boom, he could use the devices. that happens in the beginning.

But I think people forgot about it as they read because later something happens and the MC becomes a slave and the slave magic morphs his ability in such a way that now everyone that sees his master as their leader and follows them can use the devices and can even build them by themselves. and this time I explained that more bluntly with a direct example, using her maid and a random guard but I think it wasn't enough.

The problem is that I received some comments on RR saying they find it odd that the people of the world didn't think about making devices like the MC built for themselves because now he is even teaching how to with classes and stuff, but by that point in the story i already explained that only nobles could use magic and even they didn't use much, it was more a status symbol, different from before were everyone could use magic... but i explained as the story progresses trying to be organic about it.

I wonder if, when I do a rewrite, I need to be more direct in explaining things and not let people assume how things work by themselves.

I responded to the person explaining and all, but to me, if he had that doubt, I failed, and also the fact that I kind of destroyed the MC uniqueness in a way, but he has other things for him and all, and the whole point of him is that he can't do things alone like the hero; he needs to have others doing and creating new things.

This is my first story and English is not my native language so I can see something like this happening. I know that I have a long way to go but yeah, should I be more direct?
 

Kalliel

Grind, Future, A Beautiful Star
Joined
Aug 8, 2023
Messages
516
Points
133
I think you need to work on your linguistic skills before that. Try focus on clarity.
 

Hans.Trondheim

Low energy is king!
Joined
Jan 22, 2021
Messages
1,973
Points
153
I didn't want to ask for writing tips because maybe some people would think I was promoting my story so better to post here.

To put it bluntly, my story is about a guy that has memories of the past but just the memories are not reincarnation; those memories come from a hero that was reincarnated from earth and all that. not really that complex.

For the hero in the past, he could use runes to build or improve devices or enchant armor and stuff, for example, Magictech, which he used for his party and himself sometimes and never bothered to teach anyone like any overpower protagonist would. My MC has that as his power; that is the difference; now he needed to give permission to people so that they could use his devices. In the beginning of the story, he didn't even think about teaching to anyone, as everything was still new and he needed to learn how it works. Again, he is not the hero himself, just the memories, and it is not like the hero even tried to build the things he was trying to.

Instead of saying it out loud, I hinted at putting the MC showing a device to a blacksmith who was his only friend and at first he could not use it, but then he said in a way in the middle of the conversation something like "See, now you can use it" while holding the hand of the blacksmith and boom, he could use the devices. that happens in the beginning.

But I think people forgot about it as they read because later something happens and the MC becomes a slave and the slave magic morphs his ability in such a way that now everyone that sees his master as their leader and follows them can use the devices and can even build them by themselves. and this time I explained that more bluntly with a direct example, using her maid and a random guard but I think it wasn't enough.

The problem is that I received some comments on RR saying they find it odd that the people of the world didn't think about making devices like the MC built for themselves because now he is even teaching how to with classes and stuff, but by that point in the story i already explained that only nobles could use magic and even they didn't use much, it was more a status symbol, different from before were everyone could use magic... but i explained as the story progresses trying to be organic about it.

I wonder if, when I do a rewrite, I need to be more direct in explaining things and not let people assume how things work by themselves.

I responded to the person explaining and all, but to me, if he had that doubt, I failed, and also the fact that I kind of destroyed the MC uniqueness in a way, but he has other things for him and all, and the whole point of him is that he can't do things alone like the hero; he needs to have others doing and creating new things.

This is my first story and English is not my native language so I can see something like this happening. I know that I have a long way to go but yeah, should I be more direct?
Just wanna try to help translating your idea, but let me ask first, are you perhaps a Filipino? If you are, feel free to message me your problem in Filipino, and I can translate it for you in this thread.
 

Azure_Fog

More stabby, more happy~
Joined
Sep 5, 2023
Messages
271
Points
133
As others have stated, try to work on conveying thoughts clearly. Your post was a mess to read.
To put it bluntly, my story is about a guy that has memories of the past but just the memories are not reincarnation; those memories come from a hero that was reincarnated from earth and all that. not really that complex.
The semicolon here is completely unnecessary. A semicolon technically can be used that way I believe, but these are completely independent thoughts. If replaced by a period, the sentences would still work independently. It also messes with pacing but I’ll save that for later.

Also, you didn’t capitalize the ‘n’ after the period in the last sentence.

Third, no this isn’t simple and is very complex. The ideas of identity and whether or not you are the person you have memories of is a pretty deep philosophical idea.

Tell me, if I make a clone of you, with all the same memories as you, is it you? What if I erase one at random? Is that you?

Now to put that in a more understandable manner, say I teleport you. To do this I deconstruct you and move every particle that makes you one at a time to a new location. Your memories are transferred too. Is that still you? Or is that the clone?

Or perhaps another idea. Say I start moving bits of your memories over to the clone. Only one of you ever has the memories at one time. If I transfer all the memories, is the clone you? If so, when does the old you stop being you?

Now these ideas may seem isolated from the idea of having someone else’s memories, but imagine the clone as another person instead.

Or perhaps another way to think about it. How do you know your memories are real? If o transferred your mind to a new body, one that’s completely different, how do you know you are still you? Are you another person who only has the memories of the other person?

Also all of this can be avoided simply by changing how the memories are expressed or obtained.

For the hero in the past, he could use runes to build or improve devices or enchant armor and stuff, for example, Magictech, which he used for his party and himself sometimes and never bothered to teach anyone like any overpower protagonist would. My MC has that as his power; that is the difference; now he needed to give permission to people so that they could use his devices. In the beginning of the story, he didn't even think about teaching to anyone, as everything was still new and he needed to learn how it works. Again, he is not the hero himself, just the memories, and it is not like the hero even tried to build the things he was trying to.
Okay this is long enough I have to break it up.
armor and stuff, for example, Magictech, which
That cannot be a comma. Commas cannot connect 2 full sentences. If you want them to be one sentence, use a semicolon. Otherwise, use a period.
My MC has that as his power; that is the difference; …
Semicolons here are unnecessary and break the flow. This section, due to the fact that semicolons cannot be used here, breaks. As a native English speaker, I removed them completely while reading, making the thought expressed seem obsolete as it was rushed over.

To fix this you have 2 options. Use periods or use em dashes (—). These separate the thought completely and place emphasis on it. (Also commas won’t work as these are 3 independent sentences)

Finally, your writing here is a pronoun soup. Generally speaking, if you use too many pronouns, the proper noun to which they refer becomes muddled.
Ex. Replace:
which he used for his party and himself sometime
With:
which the hero used for his party and himself sometime
This also applies when 2 characters share the same pronouns.
Ex. we have 2 characters, Bob and Joe.
In the sentence “he hit him”, who hit who?
Instead of saying it out loud, I hinted at putting the MC showing a device to a blacksmith who was his only friend and at first he could not use it, but then he said in a way in the middle of the conversation something like "See, now you can use it" while holding the hand of the blacksmith and boom, he could use the devices. that happens in the beginning.
Watch what information you have already written. You’re repeating yourself here.
he said in a way in the middle of the conversation something like
Here you say “in a way” and “something like”. These both convey vagueness, but we don’t need it twice. Since it’s mentioned twice, it feels out of place due to being mentioned twice. Just like the last sentence I wrote. See the problem?

Also, run on sentences. This entire paragraph is one sentence, except the last thought. It should not be.
But I think people forgot about it as they read because later something happens and the MC becomes a slave and the slave magic morphs his ability in such a way that now everyone that sees his master as their leader and follows them can use the devices and can even build them by themselves. and this time I explained that more bluntly with a direct example, using her maid and a random guard but I think it wasn't enough.
The problem is that I received some comments on RR saying they find it odd that the people of the world didn't think about making devices like the MC built for themselves because now he is even teaching how to with classes and stuff, but by that point in the story i already explained that only nobles could use magic and even they didn't use much, it was more a status symbol, different from before were everyone could use magic... but i explained as the story progresses trying to be organic about it.
These are basically more of the same.
I wonder if, when I do a rewrite, I need to be more direct in explaining things and not let people assume how things work by themselves.
This is a fine sentence. Good job.
Second, I swear you’re addicted to semicolons. Pretty much all of them are unnecessary. (Basically just grammar)

Third, I think for major plot points it’s best to hit readers more or less in the face with it. Some might be looking beyond the surface while reading, but most likely don’t. Especially since this is a web novel and not a formal, published book.
 

Hans.Trondheim

Low energy is king!
Joined
Jan 22, 2021
Messages
1,973
Points
153
Thanks

Ah no, i'm not xD, i'm brazilian.
No matter. You being a Brazilian means you're also a brother. I dunno, but Filipinos and Brazilians are said to be bros. ????

Any case, as much as I try to understand what you want to explain to us, do not spoonfeed your readers. Those who are having difficulty in understanding your narrative might be encountering problems with the English grammar (like how we can't understand you right now, but no worries, we non-native English speakers are having this problem at the start. Just hang out with us, and you'll eventually learn to communicate properly in English), the arrangement/sequence of the events, or the story simply isn't made for them.

Try to brush up your English first, then try to correct your sentences. After that, rewrite and reupload your work. If you still receive the same feedback, look at the sequence of events. If you see no problem, the problem might be the readers themselves.

End point, continue writing. Don't be discouraged.
 
Top