A fresh start. What would you do?

just_darkjazz

Active member
Joined
Mar 11, 2024
Messages
52
Points
33
Hello. Im sure Im not alone in this but when I started working on my story I had no idea what I was doing. I had a vision, a plan, but few of the skills I required to actually see them through. I think I've improved a lot over the months that the story has been going, almost a year at this point. The story has had a lot of lows, so much so I'd hardly recomend it anyone here, or even my friends. But also a few highs that shouldn't be discounted. I'm very conflicted about what to think about it, it's not shaped up like I wanted it to but I still can't help but feel a lot of love for it. That being said I do kinda despserately need a fresh start with it.

I've always seen the sdtory as split in seasons, kind of like a TV show. Season 1 is nearing the end, should have a couple of weeks left. After that, I don't know. I took a hiatus a few months ago and the little steam the story had picked up kinda fizzled after I came back. I'm not doing it for the numbers, of course, but I still can't help but feel I might have gimped myself and think of what could have been (dellusions of grandeur, anyone? :blobthumbsup: ) If I was on the 9th chapter I would simply delete and redo. For better or worse I'm on the 90th chapter, so that option is off the table I think. I have plans for the second season, I want a tighter narrative, less distractions, better pacing, less meandering. I'm confident I can make the story something worth recomending.

My main gripe about the story is how a lot of the early chapters are very rough to get through. My format was bad, and the creative process all wrong, with long spans of time where nothing happened and the plot didn't advance at all. I think I've moved past that, and the story is all the more better now because of it. But for someone new picking the story up I can't imagine it being a good experience, slogging through a girlfailure's rumblings as she slowly learns to how to write. As I mentioned above I believe it is quite too late to redo the start to the story, and my focus should be on how to move forward to it. For that, the way I see it, I have two options (and do feel free to suggest anything I'm not seeing). Option one, stick with the original story after the end of the first season and post through the pain. Option two, release the second season to the story seperately.

Option one is for the benefit of the dedicated readers, not as many as I was hoping for but still more than I could ask for. I do everything for them, they mean the world to me. And I don't know if they would follow me on a new story, or even if it would be fair to ask them to do so. Option two would give me a second shot at building a following, and offer a more stable experience across the board. I want transiet readers stumbling upon my work to know what they are in for, and what to expect, so they can make an educated decision on whether they want to stick with me or not, something my existing story doesn't offer.

For the record I do plan on asking my readers what they think as well, and Im still a few weeks off before I have to make a choice. What would you do in my place, though?
 

Hans.Trondheim

Low energy is king!
Joined
Jan 22, 2021
Messages
1,939
Points
153
Hello. Im sure Im not alone in this but when I started working on my story I had no idea what I was doing. I had a vision, a plan, but few of the skills I required to actually see them through. I think I've improved a lot over the months that the story has been going, almost a year at this point. The story has had a lot of lows, so much so I'd hardly recomend it anyone here, or even my friends. But also a few highs that shouldn't be discounted. I'm very conflicted about what to think about it, it's not shaped up like I wanted it to but I still can't help but feel a lot of love for it. That being said I do kinda despserately need a fresh start with it.

I've always seen the sdtory as split in seasons, kind of like a TV show. Season 1 is nearing the end, should have a couple of weeks left. After that, I don't know. I took a hiatus a few months ago and the little steam the story had picked up kinda fizzled after I came back. I'm not doing it for the numbers, of course, but I still can't help but feel I might have gimped myself and think of what could have been (dellusions of grandeur, anyone? :blobthumbsup: ) If I was on the 9th chapter I would simply delete and redo. For better or worse I'm on the 90th chapter, so that option is off the table I think. I have plans for the second season, I want a tighter narrative, less distractions, better pacing, less meandering. I'm confident I can make the story something worth recomending.

My main gripe about the story is how a lot of the early chapters are very rough to get through. My format was bad, and the creative process all wrong, with long spans of time where nothing happened and the plot didn't advance at all. I think I've moved past that, and the story is all the more better now because of it. But for someone new picking the story up I can't imagine it being a good experience, slogging through a girlfailure's rumblings as she slowly learns to how to write. As I mentioned above I believe it is quite too late to redo the start to the story, and my focus should be on how to move forward to it. For that, the way I see it, I have two options (and do feel free to suggest anything I'm not seeing). Option one, stick with the original story after the end of the first season and post through the pain. Option two, release the second season to the story seperately.

Option one is for the benefit of the dedicated readers, not as many as I was hoping for but still more than I could ask for. I do everything for them, they mean the world to me. And I don't know if they would follow me on a new story, or even if it would be fair to ask them to do so. Option two would give me a second shot at building a following, and offer a more stable experience across the board. I want transiet readers stumbling upon my work to know what they are in for, and what to expect, so they can make an educated decision on whether they want to stick with me or not, something my existing story doesn't offer.

For the record I do plan on asking my readers what they think as well, and Im still a few weeks off before I have to make a choice. What would you do in my place, though?
Rewrites exist for a reason, and this is one of them. Do not be afraid to edit your work even when you already posted it, and do not make the same mistake as me that before when I was starting, I tend to delete and reupload my works, each one I believe is better than the last time. Reason? Readers have a certain threshold in which they can tolerate such 'wishy-washy' attitude as an author. On my fourth reupload of my story back in 2021, it was panned because "Huh? Hans reuploaded it again? Nah, I've read that before; this time, it's the same experience, so I'm out."

You don't want that to happen.

Now, about your second volume/season/arc, I'd advise you continue to upload it. Then, leave a message for your dedicated readers that you intend to rewrite the first volume/season/arc to improve on it. Your true supporters will understand it; after all, that's why they are your supporters!

I know of some authors here who painstakingly edited their prose in the middle of them uploading new chapters as well. @Assurbanipal_II is one of them, and his readers are fine with it.
 

Emotica

Member
Joined
Jan 21, 2026
Messages
33
Points
18
To be honest, fresh start, I wouldn’t stop. I never published my first story at all. It was probably 80% done without counting for editing, but by the end, I wasn’t proud of it. Seeing how successful some people get without refined writing abilities, I wish I just pressed full send. Then again, maybe that would’ve validated the wrong things.
 

Eldoria

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 14, 2025
Messages
1,607
Points
113
To be honest, fresh start, I wouldn’t stop. I never published my first story at all. It was probably 80% done without counting for editing, but by the end, I wasn’t proud of it. Seeing how successful some people get without refined writing abilities, I wish I just pressed full send. Then again, maybe that would’ve validated the wrong things.
What do you mean by validating the wrong things? Are you waiting for perfection to happen before you act?

Don't forget... many writers never took a creative writing course in the first place, yet they DARE to write fiction and publish it.

They learn from their mistakes, from feedback, from experience, and ultimately develop into experienced writers. Would you call what they experienced "mistakes"?
 
Last edited:

TinaMigarlo

the jury is back. I'm almost too hot for smuthub.
Joined
Jan 9, 2026
Messages
528
Points
93
OP
you have a certain number of ":bad books" to get written and out of your system
remember, OP. You only need *one* big winner of a book, to be a good author
many authors are known for "book X" or "serial friction X"... and not so much for their other stuff.
as long as every book has some improvement you've incorporated into your writing routine, its all good
my take on my own writing?
I got to run out of ways to screw the pooch sooner or later.
Look, OP
when you see some "successful book X"
do you think that's the first time that author sat down, started typing, then BANG big success happened ?
every writer has shelves of manuscripts that went nowhere.
today, though... the shelves are digital.

NOW. if you think you have some writing issues/problems.
identify what they are
have a plan to *fix* the issues
the next book?
maybe don't post every chapter as you write it.
maybe don't aim for a 597 chapter marathon.
how about 25 to 75 chapters of solid book.
post the chapters in slow release after you are *done*.

just make sure you're doing something different, that you've fixed an issue.
just show some growth on your next project.

question: are you pantsing hundreds of chapters per book? I know people do this.
 

Emotica

Member
Joined
Jan 21, 2026
Messages
33
Points
18
What do you mean by validating the wrong things? Are you waiting for perfection to happen before you act?

Don't forget... many writers never took a creative writing course in the first place, yet they DARE to write fiction and publish it.

They learn from their mistakes, from feedback, from experience, and ultimately develop into experienced writers. Would you call what they experienced "mistakes"?
By validating the wrong things, I mean it subjectively. For me, not writing (publicly) right away is the reason I got really great at outlines and poetry. In another timeline, I’d have a lot of works released from brute forcing through stories that were narratively sloppy. The path I chose, that didn’t commit to long works until my narrative skills improved, gave me a lot of time with outlines (and poetry). Everyone is different, but even though I wish I went full throttle earlier, I’m also glad I waited until I had the confidence. I did plenty of small-scale, short-form writing regardless, so it’s not like I put the pen down entirely.

I don’t think there’s any wrong way to go about it. So long as someone is getting practice, that’s a win.
 
Top