Search results

The restart Yet it gets flooded by stories that for all intents and purposes aren't isekai at all. Particularly, those with amnesia. How can it be "another" world if it's the mc's only known world? This isn't even touching in the fact of memory erasure=personality death. We all have a sense...

I described the mentality not the person.

I know but I want to be able to sort them out of results. If its fluent enough to be unnoticeable, the tag is redundant.

By definition it is, but not intent. Its exactly why the definition needs clarity.

Sad but true. Currently I can't even use the genre sort on the homepage, everything MUST be found through series finder.( what a horrible name) guess advanced search ability may as well be added there because it nearly useless.

This is why I want a non native English tag. 99% of the tag abuse comes from Chinese crap.

Now it's more personal insults? Definitely loser mentality. They even went through the effort of making memes because they can't handle the debate. That's not just loser mentality, but sore loser mentality.

The words of loser changing the subject.

Such an insightful reply. Glad to see that since stargate and star trek now meet your definition of isekai, that you can see how ridiculous it is.

That would make any isekai where they eventually return reverse isekai then. What's that one where the mc falls in the dungeon and transmutes stuff? Shoves the rod up the dragons booty and get with the rabbit girl. He eventually goes home and the story continues. I don't remember that ever being...

I'm using those as examples of the majority rule not being worth anything. It's actually very dangerous and has lead to innumerable deaths that easily illustrate that it's worthless as a metric.

Since when does isekai translate to another universe? And also they go to other universes multiple times in both Stargate and star trek. Democracies always failed due to the tyranny of the majority. That same tyranny of the majority lead to slavery and nazis killing jews. That is not a...

I don't really like the idea of expanding it that far, but I'll compromise as long as you agree that their sense of self should be complete. Being a different person on the other side of the isekai tunnel mentally, is essentially the same as a new person being born their with some memories from...

Sounds exactly like someone who thinks votes online matter in deciding an argument. The very first thing you said was I can't change meanings while changing the meaning of "world"

From the language I can't tell you likely have bots or multiple accounts. The votes mean nothing especially online when Asian countries are concerned. There is a certain one with a distinct lack of morals.

Run away when you lose I see. At the very least reply to my last reply. Amd as I said it has to be the "same person" on both ends of the isekai tunnel. The sense of self must be continuous throughout. Any change kills the original meaning they never existed in two separate worlds. It's just a...

The English is failing and I'm having a hard time understanding exactly what you mean. In my opinion if you lose memories you lose your sense of self, and are dead. Even if it's just part of your memories, you aren't the same exact person anymore. Something as simple as having the memory of...

Currently the definition is "another world" not another reality. Based an your own argument you agree with me that it needs to be changed. Second that last paragraph makes no sense. Whatever you expect from isekai can be found in the fantasy genre. It can have crossover, but isekai isn't always...

And also what you expect form isekai is literally the fantasy genre. It has nothing at all to do with isekai. What the other world holds could be mundane and its isekai. Yes, there are a ton of bandwagon authors abusing tags. The key part of going to another world is having lived in a prior...

You say that, and but change the definition of world to mean reality. That argument holds no water.