But I do agree. Life is a complex thing, and a lot of the time, you can't reduce your thoughts, feelings, and beliefs into simple, mutually exclusive categories. That comes as a natural consequence of existing.
Only anime characters can be single-note, holding onto their singular ideals without faltering.
But seriously, I have never found two true things that couldn't be reconciled in some sensible, harmonious manner. If you think there is a contradiction, I have always found that further thought into it solves the matter. That is a natural consequence of truth existing.
That is indeed the most logical proposition. They could not be both true if they are truly contradictory. So if they are both true, the more logical conclusion is that are only seemingly contradictory, when in fact they are not at all. Otherwise, as already said, they would not be able to exist alongside.