Scribble Hub Forum

Assurbanipal_II
Assurbanipal_II
Tsuru
Tsuru
Sorry ..... My stomach cant bear anymore regular EN novels. ?‍♀️
Also your genre (dark/little girl) was already a genre that is not high in my list of preferences.... =/

And the 2 top reviews (each series) had really good points that i would very likely say.
Tsuru
Tsuru
-Too verbose/descriptive



-Twisted FMC
typical holier than thou, reality warping, overpowered fool
-Bitting too much you can chew
The protagonist fancies herself a philosopher and thinks herself a brilliant tactician. She is neither, and displays this to a painful degree.
Tsuru
Tsuru
As interesting as insane characters can be, they are difficult to write.
Unfortunately, Asami isn't an in interesting insane protagonist, she is a Xianxia young master.
She was pointlessly arrogant before she became powerful and remains so after she does become skilled. There is no noticeable character growth, negative or positive in any meaningful way.
Tsuru
Tsuru
As interesting as insane characters can be, they are difficult to write.
Unfortunately, Asami isn't an in interesting insane protagonist, she is a Xianxia young master.
She was pointlessly arrogant before she became powerful and remains so after she does become skilled. There is no noticeable character growth, negative or positive in any meaningful way.
Tsuru
Tsuru
Throughout the series, Asami looks down on those around her, dismissing them as idiots. She has a narrow viewpoint and enjoys monologuing about how right she is. While not uncommon in novels, it is annoying.
The more serious issue is that her idiot field and plot armor often conspire to make her correct when she shouldn't be
Tsuru
Tsuru
The issue with tactics is similar. Those around her sometimes have decent ideas in spite of the idiot field. 90% of the time she dismisses them and posits her own, usually inferior, plan. Everyone rejects her plan. The other plan, which was almost always better than her own plan, will fail spectacularly.
Tsuru
Tsuru
Often, when she doesn't get her way she will force it, sometimes even killing people to move things along. She doesn't listen to orders, acts on her own, bad mouths her superiors and is never punished for it in any meaningful way.
Tsuru
Tsuru
=/

After reading all this just now, i need to describe that
i'm not fan of

1) evil MCs
2) arrogant MCs
3) plot armor
4) illogical things
5) crazy MCs
Tsuru
Tsuru
>
1) If i did, i would have read Reverend Insanity

2) If i did, i wouldnt drop this timetravel novel where MC is son of minister that keep berating the emperor (i expected gold, i found copper) (MC is like a arrogant delinquent/evil soldier)

4) I like when things make sense. As i am quite rational myself.
I also like irrational things but the premise is the quality/humor/theme of it.

5) Same reasoning (1)
Tsuru
Tsuru
3) I like plot armor but like all things there are good ones and bad ones.
And well, when it help someone wrong/evil, its like a evil plot armor.
and give the impression that "villainy is rewarded and good people not" which is a big problem itself in current reality.
tldr : evil bakarina plot armor
Or CNs where the enemy survive EVERYTIME the MC
Assurbanipal_II
Assurbanipal_II
Going read the story instead of listening to two TROLLS!!! One is smurf account sent by a rival author I can identify for certain. The other is an idiot who had a Naruto fanfic on their own and doesn't even know the story.
  • Wow
Reactions: Tsuru
Assurbanipal_II
  • Love
Reactions: Tsuru
Assurbanipal_II
Assurbanipal_II
:blob_upset: I had them nailed down on several points of their review in a pm. They never replied. They never responded again. No comment on any other story. No other review on any other story.
  • Sad
Reactions: Tsuru
Assurbanipal_II
  • Sad
Reactions: Tsuru
Assurbanipal_II
Assurbanipal_II
They never replied again.
  • Sad
Reactions: Tsuru
Top