Feedback On My Novel Series

StrideInTheNight

New member
Joined
Dec 16, 2025
Messages
3
Points
3
Hello, hello! I've spent about 5 or so years writing my own original series. I actually finished two books. I started on my third one mid last year, but I've never gotten feedback on them online. They've accumulated a little over 2k views all together, but I'm not sure what to take from silent views.

I'd be grateful for some feedback. Even if it's someone evaluating one chapter. Just tell me your honest opinion.

 

Rolanov

Kin-Slayer
Joined
Jan 22, 2026
Messages
225
Points
63
Hello, hello! I've spent about 5 or so years writing my own original series. I actually finished two books. I started on my third one mid last year, but I've never gotten feedback on them online. They've accumulated a little over 2k views all together, but I'm not sure what to take from silent views.

I'd be grateful for some feedback. Even if it's someone evaluating one chapter. Just tell me your honest opinion.

Hmm, i read chapter 1, but i don't know why it feels like fell flat mate.

I'm very easy person to be impressed, but this time, I didn't even catch the interesting plot. Also, I recommend you to change cover too, to make it more interesting.
 

StrideInTheNight

New member
Joined
Dec 16, 2025
Messages
3
Points
3
Oh, I see. Thank you for taking time out of your day to give it a read. This does indeed help to know.
Hmm, i read chapter 1, but i don't know why it feels like fell flat mate.

I'm very easy person to be impressed, but this time, I didn't even catch the interesting plot. Also, I recommend you to change cover too, to make it more interesting.
Oh, I see. Thank you for taking time out of your day to give it a read. This does indeed help to know.
 

Rolanov

Kin-Slayer
Joined
Jan 22, 2026
Messages
225
Points
63
Oh, I see. Thank you for taking time out of your day to give it a read. This does indeed help to know.
Absolutely. Actually, your story idea is good, but the delivery on the chapter needs improvement. To gather more views, interesting cover needed since your story actually not popular genre on SH.
 

StrideInTheNight

New member
Joined
Dec 16, 2025
Messages
3
Points
3
Were you looking for feedback on book two specifically? Or would you be ok if I started with book 1?
Oh. Book 2 is fine. I think every chapter represents me as a writer, so there is no "wrong choice". I appreciate you considering it.
 

Eldoria

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 14, 2025
Messages
1,971
Points
113
I'd be grateful for some feedback. Even if it's someone evaluating one chapter. Just tell me your honest opinion.
Okay. It's my honest impression after reading your chapter.
This morning, without breaking what seems to be an unspoken tradition, Galivinth is wearing his usual fashion of a black hoodie over a black t-shirt, black fitted jeans, and of course his equally as black pair of converse sneakers. Naeth on the other hand is sporting a red and thin wool sweater with its sleeves both rolled up above his elbows. His multi-task device that resembles a thick leather bracer with a watch sewn into it on his right wrist, while a yellow thin rubber band loosely rests around his left wrist. On his legs are snow-white cargo pants that are tucked into the red shin-high steel-toe boots on his feet.
Dude... what's the point of that description in the plot?

This static description slows down pacing (time freezes in the story world).

Insert descriptions of the character's appearance in action to speed up pacing.

"Oh, morning there. I didn't know you were going out today." Naeth remarks as the two stand before each other.

"Hey, man. I'm just going to the store to pick up some school supplies, is all." Galivinth responds as he tucks his hands away into the pockets of his jeans.

"School? I see. I hadn't thought to ask about your academic studies since meeting you..."

"It's not a big deal or anything. I mean, besides the fact that we can't hang out as much as we have been once I go back on Monday. You can come with me if you want. I've only got this one thing to do and then I'm probably heading straight back home." Galivinth tells him.

"Certainly. Though, I'm not quite sure why you attending school would prevent us from spending time together." Naeth responds. Then the two boys begin walking side-by-side toward their destination.

"Well, my classes start at 8:45am Monday through Friday, and school doesn't let out until 3:25pm. Then I have to get homework done, but after that I'm free to do what I want until 9pm. Which is when I have go to bed to rest for the next day of school." Galivinth explains.

"Ah, understandable. I... think? You'll retire for bed every night at 9pm? Seems like earthlings don't have a lot of energy."

"...Now that you mention it, I have noticed it takes me just about two whole days to get to the point of possibly getting some sleep. Which... wasn't really a thing before I met my dad. How long do you usually stay up for?"

"Typically, three earth days, but occasionally when I want to stay up even longer, I can just about manage four days before I finally tucker out." Naeth answers, earning a questioning look from his cousin.

"FOUR days? That's insane, dude... What do you even do with all that time you spend awake?"
Dude... do you think readers can understand who's speaking in that dialogue?

You start with a long dialogue before the reader even knows your characters' personalities. As a result, the characters' voices feel similar.

Long dialogues should be given after the reader gets to know your character. You need to provide adequate character introduction: narrate the character's identity and personality using showing through the interactions between the characters and their environment in an organic way.

Well, that's my little feedback.

Regards.

Edit: A name tag alone isn't enough to make a character feel alive. A name is empty... what makes a name meaningful is the character's identity and personality.

If you name a character before introducing their identity and personality, readers will find the name meaningless. They'll easily forget the character's name because it lacks emotional resonance.
 
Last edited:
Top