What would you do if your story became insanely popular?

Omarfaruq

Cute, polite and poor boy
Joined
Jan 12, 2026
Messages
324
Points
93
Imagine this: your story suddenly blows up—millions of readers, endless comments, fan art everywhere, people talking about it nonstop.
Would you:
1.Keep writing exactly as you do now?
2.Speed up updates to meet the hype?
3.Start planning spin-offs or extra content?
4.Or just take a step back and enjoy the chaos?
I’m curious how other writers would handle sudden fame for their story. Share your thoughts!
 

Eldoria

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 14, 2025
Messages
1,589
Points
113
I’m curious how other writers would handle sudden fame for their story. Share your thoughts!
My fiction isn't popular... and probably never will be. But let's imagine a popular scenario...

Readers might call me a nobledark mommy author. Memories of Marry and her little daughter, Caelan, might live on in readers' minds.

Fandoms are rife. Fans are theorizing... about Marry's resurrection. Guessing what secret her little daughter holds that could change the history of the world. And who are Marry's sisters who will disturb the peaceful life of mother and little daughter in the next arc, along with the potential thematic and conflict of the story. My response?

I will just smile from behind the screen. I will keep writing this fiction until it is finished. I might reply to some reader comments. But I will also probably ignore the annoying questions.

I will keep writing... and writing until it is finally finished. Finally, I will edit it for paperback format and publish it to a self-publishing platform.

Well, this is just a scenario... unfortunately my fiction is still ongoing and still far from the standard of 'worth reading'.

And becoming popular? That's still a mirage.
 

JayMark

It's Not Easy Being Nobody, But Somebody Has To.
Joined
Jul 31, 2024
Messages
1,636
Points
128
Imagine this: your story suddenly blows up—millions of readers, endless comments, fan art everywhere, people talking about it nonstop.
Would you:
1.Keep writing exactly as you do now?
2.Speed up updates to meet the hype?
3.Start planning spin-offs or extra content?
4.Or just take a step back and enjoy the chaos?
I’m curious how other writers would handle sudden fame for their story. Share your thoughts!
I would quit my day job and set myself on a writing scedule of at least eight hours a day, five days a week.
But I needn't worry about that.
 

ElijahRyne

A Hermit that’s NOT that Lazy, currentlycomplainen
Joined
Aug 12, 2021
Messages
1,813
Points
153
Imagine this: your story suddenly blows up—millions of readers, endless comments, fan art everywhere, people talking about it nonstop.
Would you:
1.Keep writing exactly as you do now?
2.Speed up updates to meet the hype?
3.Start planning spin-offs or extra content?
4.Or just take a step back and enjoy the chaos?
I’m curious how other writers would handle sudden fame for their story. Share your thoughts!
Finish it and adapt it into a VN.
 

rileykifer

Member
Joined
Dec 13, 2025
Messages
55
Points
18
Honestly? I would panic over the pressure and high expectations. When you've barely got anyone reading it, you don't have to worry about people pestering you over next updates. You can write the story however you want, and take it in whatever direction you want. You don't have to worry about people getting mad over not catering to their ships, or that you killed off a certain character, or that you made x do y. You don't have to worry about getting canceled because you were somehow accidentally problematic. No Experts catching mistakes in your research and being obnoxious about it. No nitpickers. But if you're insanely popular, you have all these people to please at the risk of getting hate mail and doxxed.

It would be nice for my stuff to get love and appreciation, but I would not handle that level of popularity well at all. I'd try to keep calm and update as normal, but I'd have a lot of anxiety over every decision.
 

Omarfaruq

Cute, polite and poor boy
Joined
Jan 12, 2026
Messages
324
Points
93
My fiction isn't popular... and probably never will be. But let's imagine a popular scenario...

Readers might call me a nobledark mommy author. Memories of Marry and her little daughter, Caelan, might live on in readers' minds.

Fandoms are rife. Fans are theorizing... about Marry's resurrection. Guessing what secret her little daughter holds that could change the history of the world. And who are Marry's sisters who will disturb the peaceful life of mother and little daughter in the next arc, along with the potential thematic and conflict of the story. My response?

I will just smile from behind the screen. I will keep writing this fiction until it is finished. I might reply to some reader comments. But I will also probably ignore the annoying questions.

I will keep writing... and writing until it is finally finished. Finally, I will edit it for paperback format and publish it to a self-publishing platform.

Well, this is just a scenario... unfortunately my fiction is still ongoing and still far from the standard of 'worth reading'.

And becoming popular? That's still a mirage.
You’re only focusing on the worst-case scenarios. Many authors once thought they’d never be famous, yet they still became successful.
 

L1aei

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 19, 2025
Messages
1,052
Points
113
Years ago, one of my novels did become popular.

It was the novel I hated the most.

So... that was awkward. :sweat_smile:


1.Keep writing exactly as you do now?

I did, but I was also heading into rough waters with my physical and mental health at the time. So, I kept writing as I did as I was. And then I had editors. They did a lot on many of my novels... except for the one that became popular. Go figure. :blob_awkward:

Today? I'd keep writing as I do, but I'm going to be writing more often here than there. I'm here to prevent boredom. I know readers who enjoy good works have high expectations. If I start trying to meet those expectations, that's not fun anymore; that's work, and I ain't even getting paid. :blob_catflip:

2.Speed up updates to meet the hype?

No. Even then, I wrote for myself. I didn't even call myself an author, but a writer then. I wrote. It was what I did, and it is still what I do. I'm writing now, a lot, but nobody would call this me being an author, right?

3.Start planning spin-offs or extra content?

That was done ahead, before popularity had ever been a thing. It was a series with prequels, sequels, and even paraquels. All the outlines were there, I wrote them, then the editors rewrote them, and I looked at what was being changed and I was like... fuck this. I genuinely remember one chapter that had been written, then revised by the editors, and when I published it, I reread it again. And then I rewrote it, live as a published chapter on the platform, because I realized the editors didn't comprehend intimacy at all. It was almost as if when they got to those points in the chapter, they wanted it to be mechanically anatomical. Dude, WTF? That's... that's telling me somebody never got laid before. :blob_no:

4.Or just take a step back and enjoy the chaos?

Yeah, I did that later when I wasn't able to write anymore. Today, if anything I wrote became popular, I'd be wondering "Why?" because most of what I've written are fanfictions. Like, dude... the original content is what's popular, and the work I did is the rejected flair on the coattails; the what-ifs scenarios that the original author may have thought of but ultimately said "Nah."
 

Omarfaruq

Cute, polite and poor boy
Joined
Jan 12, 2026
Messages
324
Points
93
Years ago, one of my novels did become popular.

It was the novel I hated the most.

So... that was awkward. :sweat_smile:
I wouldn't say it's awkward. It just says the thing you hate others like?
 

TinaMigarlo

the jury is back. I'm almost too hot for smuthub.
Joined
Jan 9, 2026
Messages
517
Points
93
sounds like, being successful.
I don't understand the concept.
is that, like, when people *like* what you do?
they're happy you do it, tell you to do it more?
like I said... I don't grasp the concept.

funny true story (which is kinda my thing)
at work every Monday, there's customers milling around.
all workers have their own couple favorite customers. Those you talk to, they stop to say hello and gab.
One of mine, an old lady. She always had a book or one of those old "Ellery Queen" magazines.
I nicknamed her "Ellery", never did remember her real name (I'm bad with names, I know you by my nickname I give you)
We had the obligatory "book talk". we had a few authors in common we had read.
She listened to my book I was writing, me giving her the basic idea.

she asked me if I ever heard of author X.
because several of my authors, were authors thaty had endorsed *her* favorite author.
plus, she wanted me to read a couple of his books. She said my story had some similarities, I should see how he did it.
the author was now dead, but a lot of my *favorite* authors? All unpaid, were saying *this* author, was who inspired them to write.
she said after I read his work, I would "see" where Clive Cussler's Dirk Pitt, was derived from this guy.

she was right. Several of my favorite authors? All openly credited this dead author with everything they did.
I was doing a few things similar to how he did them. I decided, this is how I do things now.
if he was good enough to be the hero for several of my favorite authors? No better guy to be my hero, too.

now.
I just related that story, to tell you *this* one.
I always include some or a lot of sex in my books. "Ellery" hated that.
so, if i wrote something that had limited or what she called "normal" little bit of sex, fine.
I *want* this old lady to read one of my books. So I set out to do that.
I was getting almost done, and...
Ellery died.
She gave me a great gift right before she died, though.

New kid at work starts there right after this.
I *finally* got someone at work, speaks my language.
he can read and write. He reads books. We share "online jokes" many wouldn't get.
he wants to read that book. I do my happy dance. First reader.
he gets halfway through, says he'll finish it when the busy season at his home work is done again.
says its fine, he likes it.

I come into work, he had started reading it again. I do my happy dance, he still likes it.
Remember Ellery died?
this kid, dies.

so, the joke at work is...
my book is cursed.
if you read it, you die.
if you so much to *plan* to read it?
you die.

I appreciate the weird sense of humor, but...
not exactly a confidence builder, you know.

"success" right now, is about thirty readers. total.
but, 15 of them? Are reading *that* book.
so far, none of them have died.
I don't think, anyways.
 

Nolff

An attractive male of unspecified gender.
Joined
Aug 10, 2023
Messages
2,126
Points
153
Imagine this: your story suddenly blows up—millions of readers, endless comments, fan art everywhere, people talking about it nonstop.
Would you:
1.Keep writing exactly as you do now?
2.Speed up updates to meet the hype?
3.Start planning spin-offs or extra content?
4.Or just take a step back and enjoy the chaos?
I’m curious how other writers would handle sudden fame for their story. Share your thoughts!
Dunno, really.

Never thought that I'd be famous.

But if I were, since you asked, I'd probably be beaming with smile whilst hiding my emotions perfectly. And definitely expecting the hype to fall off bit by bit and back to being not famous at all. Engaging with the people who likes my novel is great, but I'm probably gonna do an error or two if given the chance.

Yeah no, I still got my study to think about.
 

TinaMigarlo

the jury is back. I'm almost too hot for smuthub.
Joined
Jan 9, 2026
Messages
517
Points
93
in private?
I have some people around me, you know the type.
one in particular, though.
I'd rub his nose in my book cover, like a puppy that pissed on the carpet.
I'm generally not like that, but... you know.
he earned it.
 

L1aei

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 19, 2025
Messages
1,052
Points
113
sounds like, being successful.
I don't understand the concept.
is that, like, when people *like* what you do?
they're happy you do it, tell you to do it more?
like I said... I don't grasp the concept.

funny true story (which is kinda my thing)
at work every Monday, there's customers milling around.
all workers have their own couple favorite customers. Those you talk to, they stop to say hello and gab.
One of mine, an old lady. She always had a book or one of those old "Ellery Queen" magazines.
I nicknamed her "Ellery", never did remember her real name (I'm bad with names, I know you by my nickname I give you)
We had the obligatory "book talk". we had a few authors in common we had read.
She listened to my book I was writing, me giving her the basic idea.

she asked me if I ever heard of author X.
because several of my authors, were authors thaty had endorsed *her* favorite author.
plus, she wanted me to read a couple of his books. She said my story had some similarities, I should see how he did it.
the author was now dead, but a lot of my *favorite* authors? All unpaid, were saying *this* author, was who inspired them to write.
she said after I read his work, I would "see" where Clive Cussler's Dirk Pitt, was derived from this guy.

she was right. Several of my favorite authors? All openly credited this dead author with everything they did.
I was doing a few things similar to how he did them. I decided, this is how I do things now.
if he was good enough to be the hero for several of my favorite authors? No better guy to be my hero, too.

now.
I just related that story, to tell you *this* one.
I always include some or a lot of sex in my books. "Ellery" hated that.
so, if i wrote something that had limited or what she called "normal" little bit of sex, fine.
I *want* this old lady to read one of my books. So I set out to do that.
I was getting almost done, and...
Ellery died.
She gave me a great gift right before she died, though.

New kid at work starts there right after this.
I *finally* got someone at work, speaks my language.
he can read and write. He reads books. We share "online jokes" many wouldn't get.
he wants to read that book. I do my happy dance. First reader.
he gets halfway through, says he'll finish it when the busy season at his home work is done again.
says its fine, he likes it.

I come into work, he had started reading it again. I do my happy dance, he still likes it.
Remember Ellery died?
this kid, dies.

so, the joke at work is...
my book is cursed.
if you read it, you die.
if you so much to *plan* to read it?
you die.

I appreciate the weird sense of humor, but...
not exactly a confidence builder, you know.

"success" right now, is about thirty readers. total.
but, 15 of them? Are reading *that* book.
so far, none of them have died.
I don't think, anyways.

This... I really like how you framed this. Your idea, that of success, is still one reader at a time. You're letting them in, but also protecting yourself a little because you already know the emotional cost when they drop.
 

Emotica

Member
Joined
Jan 21, 2026
Messages
33
Points
18
Dunno, really.

Never thought that I'd be famous.

But if I were, since you asked, I'd probably be beaming with smile whilst hiding my emotions perfectly. And definitely expecting the hype to fall off bit by bit and back to being not famous at all. Engaging with the people who likes my novel is great, but I'm probably gonna do an error or two if given the chance.

Yeah no, I still got my study to think about.
Well, the good news is that famous authors aren't really a thing. Sure, someone could probably pull up the Wikipedia list to prove me wrong, but give 100 people a test on modern, alive authors and have them match names, faces, and books-- you see where I'm going with this?

I'm actually kind of curious how J.K or GRRM got famous. Were they simply the last products of pre-social media fame? I have no idea what the author of LOTR, Hunger Games, or Twilight looks like. I wouldn't be surprised if their fandom does, but I'm interpreting "famous" as in a household name. It doesn't matter if you've listened to or like Taylor Swift, you know of her. I wouldn't be surprised if even J.K or GRRM can go out in public and not be recognized by a lot of people.

I think that's great though. Fame is overrated. It's funny because even if you're wildly successful, the actor that plays your main character in a movie adaption will likely be more famous than you ever will be. Such is life. Who wants to be so famous they spend the rest of their life dodging fans, and worse; haters. I'd be happy enough with my work being popular. If it was about being popular myself, books aren't exactly the mainstream currency in the modern attention economy.
 

L1aei

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 19, 2025
Messages
1,052
Points
113
Well, the good news is that famous authors aren't really a thing. Sure, someone could probably pull up the Wikipedia list to prove me wrong, but give 100 people a test on modern, alive authors and have them match names, faces, and books-- you see where I'm going with this?

I'm actually kind of curious how J.K or GRRM got famous. Were they simply the last products of pre-social media fame? I have no idea what the author of LOTR, Hunger Games, or Twilight looks like. I wouldn't be surprised if their fandom does, but I'm interpreting "famous" as in a household name. It doesn't matter if you've listened to or like Taylor Swift, you know of her. I wouldn't be surprised if even J.K or GRRM can go out in public and not be recognized by a lot of people.

I think that's great though. Fame is overrated. It's funny because even if you're wildly successful, the actor that plays your main character in a movie adaption will likely be more famous than you ever will be. Such is life. Who wants to be so famous they spend the rest of their life dodging fans, and worse; haters. I'd be happy enough with my work being popular. If it was about being popular myself, books aren't exactly the mainstream currency in the modern attention economy.

Yeah, we care about the IP, but those who wrote it? I've reading several novels on this platform, but if someone were to ask me the titles, I'd give them, except if they ask me who wrote them I'd have to double check. See what I mean? And those novels are tops here.

Why do you think I was arguing with that mod yesterday about establishing yourself before publishing anything? Readers. They care about the product, not the producer, but we see a strong reaction when controversy appears and suddenly nobody wants anything to do with that product anymore. They didn't give a shit about the maker until a stain appeared. J.K. and her personal views? GRRM and him finishing just one of his many series? Yeah...
 

corruption

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 14, 2024
Messages
177
Points
58
What would I do is any of my stories became insanely popular?
Worry about the how everyone is certifiable.
 

L1aei

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 19, 2025
Messages
1,052
Points
113
What would I do is any of my stories became insanely popular?
Worry about the how everyone is certifiable.

Okay, that response has me wishing we had a confused reaction. What do you mean by "certifiable"? No sarcasm, I'm really scratching my head at that.
 
Top