Recent content by retiisi

  1. R

    What's your checklist for giving specific rating to a story?

    I've seen people give 1star ratings to great stories, and I'm just confused if people actually feel the stories deserve 1star or they were upset about something. For me I usually rate with the following: 1 is only for stories that are an absolute and complete mess. 2 is for stories that have...
  2. R

    Author blocked me for trying to give critical feedback.

    Probably 4/5, good and easily understandable english. Pretty generic baseline setting for the world. Weird plot choises at least at the start. Holy/Corruption system sounds like a good idea but seems kinda pointless if single action player can't affect in basically any way leads to going from 1...
  3. R

    Author blocked me for trying to give critical feedback.

    Ah you're missing the point I had in the comments. My comments were about the fact that the very first fighting scene was very bareboned, and that this is not really a good thing for creating an image that the future fighting scenes would be better. With the first fighting scene being just "MC...
  4. R

    Author blocked me for trying to give critical feedback.

    tldr, It was about the story throwing the reader into the chapter with "MC joined game and easily killed all the enemies with her sword". Comment was about lacking details in the fighting scene, to which author replied that she CAN write really good fighting scenes, and only people that have...
  5. R

    Author blocked me for trying to give critical feedback.

    Author Roseofblades's Profile | Scribble Hub blocked me for trying to give feedback in their chapter comments. I was honestly trying to help them improve, but they lashed back at me as if someone daring to imply that their writing was anything short of perfect was an affront to their existence...
Top